Packages of mifepristone tablets are displayed at a household planning clinic on April 13, 2023 in Rockville, Md.
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Photographs
conceal caption
toggle caption
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Photographs
![](https://media.npr.org/assets/img/2024/04/10/gettyimages-1481952226-b61cb206b00e6660b1784ae7358b7e5cd2b5017f-s1200.jpg)
Packages of mifepristone tablets are displayed at a household planning clinic on April 13, 2023 in Rockville, Md.
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Photographs
After months of questions on what abortion insurance policies he helps, Donald Trump finally addressed the issue this week, first in a video Monday on social media, saying it is as much as states to determine their abortion legal guidelines. That assertion left most of the greatest questions on his stance unanswered.
On Wednesday Trump offered a bit extra readability, telling reporters he would not sign a federal abortion ban if one got here to his desk, regardless of supporting one at 20 weeks throughout his first time period. However he has but to deal with the potential for the FDA to limit abortion capsules, which social conservatives argued for at the Supreme Court in March. And he didn’t discuss the Comstock Act, a nineteenth century legislation that some ardent abortion opponents wish to use to limit the observe.
In response to authorized consultants, Comstock might be used to cease just about all abortion within the nation, together with in locations it’s presently authorized. When NPR requested the Trump marketing campaign about his place on Comstock, they declined to deal with it instantly.
This is what it’s essential know concerning the Comstock Act, and what the results can be whether it is enforced the best way some conservatives would really like.
What’s the Comstock Act?
The Comstock Act (linked here and here on the Authorized Data Institute) is an 1873 anti-obscenity legislation, named after anti-vice crusader Anthony Comstock. The legislation, which continues to be on the books, requires banning the mailing or transport of “each obscene, lewd, lascivious, indecent, filthy or vile article, matter, factor, system, or substance.” As well as, it particularly outlaws mailing “each article or factor designed, tailored, or supposed for producing abortion.”
The intent of the legislation was not expressly about abortion, in keeping with Mary Ziegler, legislation professor on the College of California, Davis. As an alternative, it was about what Comstock and his contemporaries known as “sexual purity.”
“The concern was that if folks knew about abortion and contraception, which was additionally outlawed initially, that they’d have intercourse they should not have, simply as in the event that they, you realize, checked out pornography,” Ziegler stated.
After all, abortion capsules — in addition to many issues that could be thought of “obscene,” “lewd” and so forth — are presently despatched by means of the mail. That is as a result of the authorized interpretation of the Comstock Act was narrowed repeatedly over time.
The legislation’s abortion provisions had been rendered moot by Roe v. Wade in 1973. However with the Supreme Court docket overturning Roe in 2022, opponents of abortion rights began viewing Comstock as a solution to prohibit abortion, with out the necessity for Congress or the courts to do something.
Particularly, that coverage is promoted by “Venture 2025.”
What’s Venture 2025?
It is the shorthand identify for the 2025 Presidential Transition Venture, a gaggle of high conservative organizations that got here collectively to strategize for a possible conservative presidency beginning subsequent yr.
“That is actually a plan for conservatives to be able to hit the bottom working Day One, Jan. 20, 2025,” stated Paul Dans, a former Trump official, on C-SPAN final yr. He works on the conservative Heritage Basis and directs Venture 2025.
A serious accomplishment of that venture up to now is a 900+-page policy roadmap known as the “Mandate for Management,” readymade for a Republican president to enact upon taking workplace.
And that roadmap requires a “marketing campaign to implement the prison prohibitions” of the Comstock Act “in opposition to suppliers and distributors of abortion capsules.”
So, may that occur?
What, precisely, the Comstock Act may do is a matter of interpretation, in addition to the Division of Justice’s discretion.
Many authorized consultants, like Ziegler, say decoding the legislation to restrict abortion would undo many years of precedent. Over time, she factors out, courts interpreted Comstock to solely forestall the mailing of things for use in unlawful abortions.
The Biden administration has issued its personal studying of Comstock. In late 2022, the Workplace of Authorized Counsel stated that Comstock does not prohibit the mailing of abortion capsules “as a result of there are manifold methods wherein recipients in each state might lawfully use such medicine, together with to supply an abortion.”
That’s not the stance conservative authorized consultants take. Josh Craddock, an affiliated scholar on the conservative James Wilson Institute, refers to Comstock as a “nationwide abortion tablet trafficking ban.”
“An easy interpretation of the statute is that it prohibits all interstate cargo or sale of abortion medicine and units, no matter whether or not state legislation permits abortion,” Craddock says. (There was dispute amongst authorized consultants NPR consulted as as to if Comstock’s prohibitions would apply to in-state transport of abortion capsules.)
Stopping the cargo of capsules would considerably curb abortion: Medicine abortions account for the majority of all abortions in the U.S.
What may the opposite implications of Comstock be?
It is value noting that whereas Venture 2025 focuses particularly on the transport of abortion capsules, Comstock refers to banning the mailing of something utilized in abortions.
Meaning the DOJ may implement the legislation far more broadly than capsules, and successfully finish abortion within the U.S., says David Cohen, legislation professor at Drexel College.
“If you cannot use the mail, FedEx, UPS, no matter, to get provides, tools, devices or capsules, how are you going to run your operation as an abortion supplier?” he stated.
Craddock agrees: “It has the potential to successfully be a nationwide prohibition in opposition to abortion and safety for unborn kids,” he stated.
That is why the controversy round Comstock is among the greatest fears amongst abortion rights supporters forward of November’s elections. As a result of the legislation is so broad, Ziegler provides, it might be used to cease the transport of issues nicely past gadgets utilized in abortions. She factors out, for instance, that the legislation does not outline “abortion.”
“If you happen to do not agree on what abortion is, it is also unclear what that abortion ban provision interpretation would imply,” she stated. Some abortion rights opponents, for instance, contemplate use of the morning-after Plan B pill to be abortion.
There’s one more means the legislation may have far-reaching results: It has a five-year statute of limitations, in keeping with Craddock.
“If a Republican, for instance, had been to be elected in November, that administration may prosecute violations of the nationwide abortion tablet trafficking ban which can be occurring now,” he stated.
Has Comstock gained traction exterior of Venture 2025?
Comstock has gained traction with many highly effective Republicans. Final month, Supreme Court docket Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas cited the legislation – seemingly approvingly – during oral arguments in a case concerning the availability of abortion capsules.
Erin Hawley, the legal professional arguing for limiting the capsules, cited it as nicely:
“The Comstock Act says that medicine shouldn’t be mailed, both by means of the mail or by means of frequent carriers. So we expect that the plain textual content of that, Your Honor, is fairly clear,” she stated.
As well as, nine Republican senators in early 2023 wrote letters to the heads of main pharmacy chains, warning them in opposition to distributing abortion capsules. The senators specifically identified Comstock’s five-year statute of limitations, which means that if chains distribute the capsules now, they may theoretically be prosecuted throughout a Trump administration.
Abortion restrictions are proving unpopular. Would Trump use it?
NPR requested the Trump marketing campaign for his place on Comstock. The marketing campaign didn’t reply the query. As an alternative, they stated in an announcement, “President Trump helps preserving life however has additionally made clear that he helps states’ rights.”
The silence on the difficulty could also be strategic. One main Comstock proponent, Jonathan Mitchell, advised the New York Instances this yr that he hopes Trump does not know concerning the legislation, as a result of “I simply don’t need him to shoot off his mouth.” He added that he thinks anti-abortion-rights teams must also maintain quiet.
That is smart to Cohen at Drexel.
“They know [the issue is] not going to win electorally, which is why they need Donald Trump to be quiet about it,” he stated. “And so they know they don’t seem to be going to cross a nationwide abortion ban as a result of that will not get by means of Congress. So that they’re different methods to do it.”
Mitchell wouldn’t discuss to NPR on the report for this story. NPR additionally tried to succeed in Gene Hamilton, the Trump administration official who wrote the Venture 2025 “Mandate for Management” chapter advocating for the Comstock Act. We obtained no response. Susan B. Anthony Professional-Life America, a number one anti-abortion-rights group concerned in Venture 2025, pointed us to The Heritage Basis.
The Heritage Basis — which, once more, led Venture 2025 — additionally declined to remark for this story.
For his half, Craddock — who desires to limit abortion by way of Comstock — thinks the legislation is value speaking about.
“I feel it is an necessary authorized concern that folks have questions on, needs to be educated about.”
What are abortion rights supporters saying?
They’re anxious.
Jennifer Lawson, vp of organizing and electoral campaigns on the Deliberate Parenthood Federation of America, advised NPR that the group is targeted for now on attempting to reelect Joe Biden. However ought to Donald Trump win the presidency, they’re getting ready for potential coverage outcomes.
“We’re doing state of affairs planning,” she stated, together with planning potential authorized challenges. “It is analyzing the guarantees that Donald Trump is making and dealing by means of what which means as a company for us and what we would want to battle and the way we will shield entry in as many locations as doable.”
Minnesota Democratic Sen. Tina Smith is presently pushing to repeal Comstock, although it isn’t clear how the repeal may cross a intently divided Congress.
The Biden marketing campaign, which is making abortion a serious a part of their marketing campaign in opposition to Trump this yr, had this to say: “Trump’s excessive allies have already written the playbook to wipe out entry to abortion nationwide with out Congress – and so they’re able to implement it if Trump wins a second time period,” spokesperson Sarafina Chitika stated in an announcement.