A model of this story appeared in CNN’s What Issues publication. To get it in your inbox, join free here.
Midway between the 2020 and 2030 census is just not the traditional time to be speaking about redistricting, or gerrymandering, however the difficulty has nonetheless taken over the political dialog.
Maybe sensing some political weak spot and fearing the lack of their Home majority, Republicans are in search of extra congressional seats. However somewhat than simply making an attempt to win them on the poll field, they’re primed to conjure extra seats by redrawing congressional maps in Texas.
Democrats, bored with being outplayed, have threatened to redraw maps in states they management, corresponding to New York and California, though it’s tougher to perform in states that, heretofore, have tried to make the method much less political.
Enabled by conservatives on the Supreme Court, whose choices have chipped away on the Voting Rights Act and given a inexperienced mild to partisan gerrymandering, the Texas effort may set off a full-on redistricting war within the years to come back.
So it’s price taking a step again to have a look at redistricting, gerrymandering and why issues work the way in which they do.
The Structure lays out the overall order of how members of Congress are divided among the many states.
The fundamental define is that this: There’s a nationwide census each 10 years to determine the variety of residents in every state. Home districts are then apportioned to the states based mostly on every state’s inhabitants.
As states develop, they’ll acquire seats. But when their inhabitants shrinks in contrast with these of different states, they’ll lose seats.
However the Structure leaves it to states to find out who, precisely, these members of Congress will signify. In states with a couple of US consultant, the method of drawing congressional maps is named redistricting. Some states give that energy to their legislatures. Others have assigned the duty of redistricting to nonpartisan or bipartisan commissions.
The Constitution says that “the entire variety of free individuals” needs to be counted. The unique model excluded “Indians not taxed” and counted solely “three fifths of all different Individuals.” That ugly acknowledgment of slavery is without doubt one of the few mentions of the nation’s unique sin within the Structure. The 14th Amendment, enacted after the Civil Conflict, eliminated the three-fifths clause and declared everybody born within the US to be a citizen.
Now, notably, Trump desires to end birthright citizenship as one strategy to deal with undocumented immigration. Republicans additionally need to exclude undocumented individuals from the census, one thing Trump tried and failed to perform in 2020.
What’s gerrymandering?
It’s the drawing of political maps for partisan acquire. Republicans and Democrats each do it, however Republicans have extra brazenly embraced the method. In follow, it’s the equal of politicians choosing their voters as an alternative of the opposite manner round, which is an inversion of the democratic course of. North Carolina, for example, leans ever-so-slightly towards Republicans in presidential elections, however because of gerrymandering, 10 of its 14 congressional seats are held by Republicans. Democrats have carried out the identical in a number of states they management.
Elbridge Gerry was a signer of the Declaration of Independence, however later, as governor of Massachusetts, he signed on to the drawing of a serpentine, salamander-like state Senate district. He’s depicted in CGI in a just lately revealed video on the White House Youtube’s page annoyed that his title has been mispronounced ever since. His title ought to sound like Gary, Indiana. However when it comes to redistricting, it’s typically pronounced with a gentle “G,” like Jerry.
What does gerrymandering seem like?
It may possibly seem like inkblot artwork. Cities might be creatively carved as much as unfold like-minded voters to different districts. They will also be strung collectively to push like-minded voters collectively. Within the present Texas map, for example, Democratic voters from Austin and San Antonio are each positioned in a single district, related by a sliver of land. Within the newly proposed map, these Democratic voters can be unfold to different districts. It depends upon what legislators drawing the map are attempting to perform. In Texas, they now need to add Republican seats.
Fairly merely, the White Home requested it to. The president’s occasion normally loses at the very least some seats throughout midterm elections and, in an effort to blunt an anticipated flip towards the him within the subsequent election, President Donald Trump asked Texas to redraw its maps. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott complied by including an agenda merchandise about redistricting to a deliberate particular session of the legislature.
Trump’s Division of Justice can be offering some cowl by arguing that a few of the state’s districts, which have been drawn to adjust to the Voting Rights Act, truly violate the US Structure.
Can Texas Democrats cease this gerrymander?
Most likely not, however they’ll strive. A bunch of state Democratic legislators have left the state with a view to carry all enterprise within the Texas legislature’s particular session to a halt. They’ve tried this tactic earlier than, together with the final time Texas Republicans did a mid-decade gerrymander in 2003. Abbott has issued civil arrest warrants and threatened to take away fleeing Democrats from workplace. The query shall be how lengthy the Democrats stay out of state, looking for refuge in blue states like Illinois and New York. The present particular session lasts for 2 extra weeks. However Abbott can at all times name one other one.
States are largely in command of the method of drawing maps for the districts they’re apportioned. It’s uncommon, however not unprecedented, to redraw these maps in the course of the last decade. Texas did it beforehand, in 2003. Mid-decade redistricting is prohibited by state legislation in some locations, however not in Texas.
Certain is, at the very least underneath federal legislation. The conservative majority on the Supreme Court so took away federal courts’ energy to assessment politically gerrymandered districts in a 2019 case.
“Federal judges don’t have any license to reallocate political energy between the 2 main political events,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote on the time, drawing the criticism of liberals on the court docket.
Sure. Beneath the Voting Rights Act of 1965, there are restrictions on how state traces might be drawn to attenuate the voting energy of minorities. The Supreme Court docket is set to hear a case this year over maps in Louisiana that would additional intestine the Voting Rights Act protections.
Districts are additionally speculated to have comparatively equal illustration, however that doesn’t at all times work out. Delaware had greater than 990,000 residents for its sole congressional district after the 2020 apportionment, however Rhode Island had about 549,000 each for its two. There are winners and losers within the apportionment course of.
Do Democrats gerrymander too?
The place they’ll, they do. In Illinois, former Vice President Kamala Harris obtained 54% of the vote in 2024, however Democrats, because of gerrymandering, received 14 of 17 congressional seats. However Democrats have handed away their energy to gerrymander in states like California, the place a nonpartisan fee attracts congressional maps. In crimson states with such commissions, they’ve incessantly been overturned by state lawmakers, corresponding to in Utah, the place a Democratic seat targeted on Salt Lake Metropolis was carved up amongst Republican seats.
Texas Republicans initially drew maps to guard incumbents. States like California, which have commission-drawn maps, incessantly have extra aggressive seats. Democrats received most of them in 2024 in California. Republicans are actually eyeing 5 extra seats in Texas based mostly on Trump’s energy within the state in 2024. They’re assuming, for example, that Latino voters who swung towards Republicans in 2024 will proceed to help Republicans. If the nation turns towards Trump, it may, in concept, backfire.
It’s a a lot more durable carry. Whereas governors in New York and California have promised to “combat fireplace with fireplace,” their arms are tied by their very own state legal guidelines.
In New York, it might take a multi-year course of to amend the state Structure.
It could be extra potential in California, however it might nonetheless require a particular election this November to primarily ask voters to undo the nonpartisan course of they created in 2008.
If the Texas maneuver snowballs into efforts to redraw maps in a number of states, Republicans would come out with extra benefit, particularly within the quick time period, according to CNN’s Arit John and Manu Raju. They write:
GOP lawmakers in states corresponding to Missouri and Florida have additionally expressed openness to new maps. Ohio, the place lawmakers should redraw their maps underneath state redistricting legal guidelines, may additionally yield extra seats.
Republicans maintain authorities majorities in 23 states in comparison with Democrats’ 15.
Will gerrymandering decide the result of the 2026 midterms?
The expectation needs to be that help for Trump and Republicans will soften within the coming election. That’s not a worth judgment on their management, however a historic actuality. Each president’s occasion going again to George W. Bush has misplaced the Home in a midterm election. That features Joe Biden’s Democrats in 2022, Trump’s Republicans in 2018, Barack Obama’s Democrats in 2010, George W. Bush’s Republicans in 2006 and Invoice Clinton’s Democrats in 1994.
The redrawing of maps may blunt the consequences of such a flip, however Democrats solely must win three extra seats to flip the Home. If there’s a wave towards Republicans, no quantity of gerrymandering is prone to save that GOP majority.
