CNN
—
Politics isn’t rocket science.
If it have been, President Donald Trump may need one thing extra to fret about in his reignited feud along with his estranged “first buddy” Elon Musk.
However nothing within the explosive and now-soured flirtation of the world’s richest man with politics suggests he has the magic contact to spark the form of inventive disruption within the Republican Occasion that he set off within the orbital and electrical car industries.
Musk’s first-among-equals standing as head of the Division of Authorities Effectivity in the beginning of Trump’s second administration is now a memory.
He’s so furious over Trump’s debt- and deficit-inflating “big, beautiful bill,” which passed the Senate on Tuesday, that he’s threatening to major each GOP lawmaker who votes for it and to arrange a brand new political occasion.
Musk does wield appreciable political weaponry. His huge fortune means he can spend huge sums on favored candidates and points. Trump is aware of this nicely, as a first-rate beneficiary of the nearly $300 million Musk threw on the 2024 election.
And because the proprietor and an obsessive person of X, Musk can name up on-line mobs in opposition to lawmakers and even Trump himself – although he’s been cautious, this time, to not single out the president instantly over the invoice.
Musk is the dominant power within the American house program. If Individuals attain Mars, they’ll most likely get there on one among Musk’s Starships. And applied sciences reminiscent of Musk’s Starlink are very important on the battlefield – because the conflict in Ukraine reveals.
But for all his huge energy, Musk has not proven a lot political dexterity, nor, apparently, created his personal base of help that might dominate the GOP.
The chainsaw he wielded on stage on the Conservative Political Motion Convention this yr was meant to represent his slashing of prices within the US authorities. Trying again, it’s a greater metaphor for the severing of his relationship with the president over Trump’s MAGA megabill.
As soon as, Musk’s alliance with Trump appeared a grasp stroke – opening an inside observe that promised even better advantages for his corporations than his already huge array of federal contracts. Trump even did a surprising sales pitch for Tesla on the South Garden of the White Home – and purchased one of many electrical automobiles himself.
So maybe it’s no shock that falling out with Trump – after which goading him right into a social media confrontation – turned out to be a political and monetary loser for Musk. Their new antagonism might expose his empire to presidential retribution.
Trump on Tuesday warned darkly that “DOGE is the monster which may have to return and eat Elon.” This can be a staggering assertion for a number of causes. First, it highlights the extent of the fracture between the patron and the person who he made probably the most highly effective personal citizen within the nation solely months in the past. Second, it’s a snapshot of a unprecedented time. Here’s a president threatening to use executive power to spoil a personal citizen and businessman. This would appear to suit most definitions of an impeachable offense, however it feels virtually unremarkable in an administration that has shattered each norm of presidential conduct.
Musk’s dalliance with Trump additionally harm him in different methods. It alienated a lot of his most enthusiastic clients, including in Europe, the place his electrical automobiles have been in style and the market worth of his corporations plunged.
And Musk’s most outstanding particular person foray into electoral politics, except for his alliance with Trump in 2024, was a disaster. His vehement rhetorical and large monetary help for a conservative candidate in a Wisconsin Supreme Court docket race backfired: the extra liberal candidate won by 10 points. The race may need been nearer had Musk and his political baggage stayed at residence. And the competition grew to become an sudden lesson that typically cash isn’t every thing in American politics.
However right here’s the largest obstacle to Musk turning into a political energy participant: Trump is indisputably probably the most important determine in American political life within the first quarter of the twenty first century.
The president has dominated the GOP for 10 years. He’s squelched the political aspirations of pretenders to his crown. Trump has a decadelong bond with the occasion base. He’s already pulled off the form of disruptive transformation of the GOP that Musk appears to be envisioning.
“My feeling is that Donald Trump is the one which has the large following,” Lee Carter, a strategist and pollster who research voters’ emotional reactions to candidates, mentioned on “CNN Information Central” on Tuesday.
“And Elon Musk definitely helped Donald Trump within the election,” Carter continued. “There’s no query about it. It gave him credibility. It gave him some voters that have been on the fence – however it wasn’t Elon Musk who was center-stage and I don’t suppose that we’re going to see folks comply with Elon Musk in the identical manner that we noticed (with) the MAGA motion.”
Musk is a current convert to Trumpism, and whereas his star shined with blinding depth late in final yr’s election and he was ubiquitous throughout the early months of the brand new administration, his break from Trump has proven that the majority energy within the MAGA motion is mirrored off its figurehead.
Vice President JD Vance was probably the most seen barometer of this energy dynamic. When the massive break-up occurred, he was compelled to decide on between Trump, who’s accountable for his present prominence, and Musk, who may very well be a helpful ally in a future presidential major marketing campaign. He picked the president.
One other key query is whether or not Musk has his personal political base.
CNN’s Aaron Blake assessed polling earlier final month that confirmed surprisingly comparative polling information amongst Republicans for Musk and Trump – not less than earlier than their newest bust-up.
However past the tech world, the place he used his rock star standing to funnel younger, disaffected male voters towards Trump, it’s not clear that Musk has a broader constituency.
By siding with the Republican Occasion’s anti-debt wing, Musk now appears a pure ally of libertarians reminiscent of Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul, who voted in opposition to the president’s invoice. However fiscal hawkishness and breaking with the GOP spending crowd isn’t a dependable path to energy – because the failed presidential campaigns of Sen. Paul and his father, former Rep. Ron Paul, demonstrated.
Nonetheless, Musk’s pledge to help Kentucky Rep. Thomas Massie, who was lambasted by the president for his opposition to the invoice and who may now face a primary challenge, may very well be important. In a single race, Musk’s wealth may very well be necessary, particular person marketing campaign contribution limits however.
It could be more durable for the Tesla tycoon to go nationwide. For one factor, he’d need to recruit major candidates prepared to tackle lawmakers supported by Trump, probably the most highly effective main occasion chief in generations.
However Musk has grand ambitions.
He promised that if the “insane spending invoice passes, the America Occasion shall be fashioned the subsequent day.” He wrote on X, “Our nation wants a substitute for the Democrat-Republican uniparty in order that the folks even have a VOICE.”
Limitations to creating a 3rd political power are daunting. For one factor, it could require shattering the emotional and historic allegiances of tens of millions of voters.
Musk’s finest guess could also be to attend out Trump – in any case, he’s a a lot youthful man. If conservatives find yourself disillusioned with the president’s legacy and politics extra broadly, the CEO might discover fertile floor for a 3rd manner.
It’s occurred earlier than. Within the 1992 election, Ross Perot’s on-again-off-again-on-again candidacy rooted in a populist name to steadiness the finances gained 19% of the vote, regardless that the Texas tycoon didn’t win a single state. On the time, Republicans blamed Perot for consuming into President George H.W. Bush’s help and serving to to elect Invoice Clinton. Three a long time on, political scientists are nonetheless arguing about what actually occurred.
Musk would want a surrogate. In contrast to Perot, he can’t run for president, since he’s a naturalized foreign-born citizen.
But when he may someway break the stranglehold of the 2 main events on US elections, he’d accomplish one thing just like the political equal of his inconceivable invention of a rocket booster that scorches a spacecraft into orbit after which returns to the launchpad to be captured by two large mechanical arms.
Even Trump thought that was superb.
“Did you see the way in which that sucker landed right this moment?” Trump mentioned at an October marketing campaign rally. However that was within the first blush of his Musk bromance.
On Tuesday, a senior White Home official informed CNN’s Kristen Holmes: “Nobody actually cares what he says anymore.”
