In 2007, eight years after turning into Venezuela’s president, Hugo Chávez revoked the license of the nation’s oldest personal tv station. Eight months into his second time period, President Donald Trump steered revoking the licenses of U.S. tv stations he believes are overly essential of him.
Since he returned to workplace in January, Trump’s remaking of the federal authorities into an instrument of his private will has drawn comparisons to elected strongmen in different international locations who used the levers of presidency to consolidate energy, punish their enemies and stifle dissent.
However these aware of different international locations the place that has occurred, together with Hungary and Turkey, say there may be one putting distinction: Trump seems to be moving more rapidly, and extra overtly, than others did.
“The one distinction is the pace with which it’s taking place,” mentioned David Smilde, who lived in Venezuela throughout Chavez’s rise and is now a professor at Tulane College.
Political enemies of the president develop into targets
The U.S. is a good distance from Venezuela or different authoritarian governments. It nonetheless has robust opposition to Trump, judges who usually verify his initiatives and a system that diffuses energy throughout 50 states, including elections, making it onerous for a president to dominate the nation. A few of Trump’s most controversial pledges, akin to revoking tv licenses, stay simply threats.
Trump has each scoffed and winked on the allegation that he’s an authoritarian.
Throughout final yr’s marketing campaign, he mentioned he wouldn’t be a “dictator” — besides, he added, “on day one” over the border. Final month, Trump instructed reporters: ”Lots of people are saying, ‘Possibly we like a dictator.’ I don’t like a dictator. I’m not a dictator.”
Even so, he has moved shortly to consolidate authority underneath the presidency, steer federal legislation enforcement to prioritize a campaign of retribution and purge the government of these not thought of sufficiently loyal.
In a latest social media publish, Trump complained to his legal professional basic, Pam Bondi, a couple of lack of prosecution of his foes, saying “JUSTICE MUST BE SERVED, NOW!!!” Days later, the Division of Justice secured a felony indictment towards former FBI Director James Comey, whom Trump has blamed for the Russian collusion investigation that dogged his first time period.
The identical day, Trump ordered a sweeping crackdown focusing on teams he alleges fund political violence. The examples he gave of victims have been solely Republicans and his attainable targets have been those that have funded Democratic candidates and liberal causes. The week earlier than, Trump’s Federal Communications Fee chairman, Brendan Carr, threatened ABC after a remark in regards to the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk by late night time host Jimmy Kimmel angered Republicans.
ABC suspended Kimmel for 5 days, however Trump threatened penalties for the community after it returned his present to the airwaves: “I feel we’re going to check ABC out on this. Let’s see how we do,” the president mentioned on his social media web site.
Trump has mentioned he’s repaying Democrats for what he says is political persecution of him and his supporters. The White Home mentioned its mission was accountability.
“The Trump administration will proceed to ship the reality to the American individuals, restore integrity to our justice system, and take motion to cease radical left-wing violence that’s plaguing American communities.” White Home spokeswoman Abigail Jackson mentioned Saturday in response to a query about comparisons between Trump and authoritarian leaders.
US unprepared for assaults on democracy from inside
Trump opened his second time period pardoning more than 1,500 people convicted of crimes throughout the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol, an try to overturn his 2020 election loss. He has threatened judges who dominated towards him, targeted law firms and universities he believes opposed him, and is making an attempt to reshape the nation’s cultural institutions.
On Saturday, the president mentioned he was going to ship troops to Portland, Oregon, “authorizing Full Power” if needed. It could be his newest deployment of troops to cities run by Democrats.
Steven Levitsky, a Harvard political scientist and co-author of the guide “How Democracies Die,” mentioned he’s continuously requested by overseas journalists how the U.S. can let Trump take such actions.
“If you happen to speak to Brazilians, South Koreans, Germans, they’ve higher antennae for authoritarians,” he mentioned. “They skilled, or have been taught by their mother and father, or the colleges, the hazard of shedding a democracy.”
Of the US, he mentioned: “This isn’t a society that’s ready for authoritarianism.”
‘America has develop into little Turkey’
Alper Coskun presumed the U.S. wouldn’t go the way in which of his native Turkey, the place he served within the authorities, together with because the nation’s director basic of worldwide safety affairs. He left as that nation’s president, Recep Erdogan, consolidated energy.
Coskun now laughs bitterly on the quip his countrymen make: Turkey wished to develop into little America, however now America has develop into little Turkey.
“It’s a really related playbook,” mentioned Coskun, now on the Carnegie Basis for Worldwide Peace. The distinction, he mentioned, is that Erdogan, first elected in 2002, needed to transfer slowly to keep away from working afoul of Turkey’s then-independent navy and enterprise neighborhood.
Trump, in distinction, has extra “openly” damaged democratic norms, Coskun mentioned.
Erdogan, who met with Trump this previous week, has had 23 years in workplace to extend his authority and has now jailed writers, journalists and a possible political rival, Istanbul mayor Ekrem Imamoglu.
“Trump is emulating Erdogan a lot quicker than I anticipated,” mentioned Henri Barkey, a Turkish professor and professional on the Council on International Relations who lives within the U.S. and has been accused by Erdogan of complicity in an tried 2016 coup, an allegation Barkey denies.
He mentioned Trump is following in Erdogan’s path in prosecuting enemies, however mentioned he has but to make use of the Justice Division to neutralize opponents working for workplace.
“Now we have to see if Trump goes to go to that subsequent step,” Barkey mentioned.
Eroding democratic norms took longer in different international locations
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has usually been cited as a mannequin for Trump. Orbán has develop into an icon to some U.S. conservatives for cracking down on immigration and LGBTQ rights. Like Trump, he misplaced an election and spent his years out of workplace planning his return.
When voters returned Orbán to energy in 2010, he moved as shortly as Trump, mentioned Kim Scheppele, who was an adviser to Hungary’s constitutional court docket and now could be a sociologist at Princeton. However there was one distinction.
To keep away from resistance, Scheppele mentioned, “Orbán had a ‘don’t scare the horses’ philosophy.” She mentioned he spent a lot of his first yr again engaged on authorized reforms and adjustments to Hungary’s structure that set him as much as consolidate energy.
In Venezuela, Chavez confronted resistance from the second he was elected, together with an unsuccessful coup in 2002. His supporters complained the nation’s largest broadcast community didn’t cowl it in actual time, and he ultimately pulled its license.
Chavez later deployed the navy as an inside police pressure and accelerated a crackdown on critics earlier than he died in workplace in 2013.
Within the U.S., Smilde mentioned, individuals belief the nation’s establishments to take care of democracy. They usually did in 2020 and 2021, when the courts, employees within the administration, and elected officers in state and federal authorities blocked Trump’s effort to overturn his election loss.
“However now, right here we’re with a extra pointed assault,” Smilde mentioned. “Right here, no one has actually seen this in a president earlier than.”
© Copyright 2025 Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials is probably not printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
