Former senior Canadian intelligence officers say Canada must be looking out for campaigns geared toward destabilizing the nation amid U.S. President Donald Trump’s escalating 51st state threats.
They usually advised CBC Information that essentially the most potent weapon wielded by the Trump administration to advance the reason for annexation would possible not be the intelligence businesses directed by Director of Nationwide Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard.
“I’d regard Mr. Musk as an issue,” mentioned Ward Elcock, who headed CSIS for a decade together with through the 9/11 assaults and in addition served as nationwide safety adviser. “I believe that is on various fronts.”
The U.S. Central Intelligence Company (CIA) has labored to destabilize many governments and nations prior to now, utilizing strategies as mundane as corruption and as drastic as assassination, however the former spy chiefs say a marketing campaign geared toward Canada would possible rely much less on cloak-and-dagger ways and extra on social media — such because the Elon Musk-owned X platform.
“Is [Trump] making an attempt to vary political opinions on this nation? In that case, that is overseas interference,” mentioned Dick Fadden, who additionally headed CSIS and served as nationwide safety adviser to former prime minister Stephen Harper.
“It is no extra acceptable from the USA than it’s from China or Russia or anyone else.”
Financial misery: Canada’s weak spot
Neil Bisson is a former CSIS intelligence officer who’s now director of the World Intelligence Data Community and teaches on the College of Ottawa’s Skilled Improvement Institute.
He says that regardless of seen indicators of Canadian unity within the face of annexation threats, there are those that are weak to the siren name, significantly among the many younger who really feel economically deprived.
“That may be one of many linchpins, one of many cracks within the armour that one other nation could be making an attempt to take advantage of,” he advised CBC Information. “When you’ve got people who’re involved about the place their subsequent meal is coming from or if they are going to get a roof over their head, that supersedes sovereignty.”
U.S. President Donald Trump is pausing tariffs — once more — on some items from Canada and Mexico. Andrew Chang breaks down two colleges of thought: whether or not Trump’s chaotic method stems from lack of planning, or a way more intentional technique.
He mentioned these Canadians might be focused by propaganda campaigns that promote American citizenship as the reply to their financial woes.
“And there might be people inside Canada who may doubtlessly be co-opted to push that narrative ahead,” mentioned Bisson.
Trump administration officers have given quite a few rationales for the tariffs towards Canada, however Trump himself has mentioned that he needs to make use of economic force to hitch Canada to the U.S. On Tuesday morning, he once more mentioned Canada may only avoid economic ruin by annexation.
“He intends clearly to try to destabilize our financial system,” mentioned Elcock. “The truth is that if Canada is admittedly impoverished, individuals could begin to consider it. That is all the time the likelihood — that not all Canadians are going to be prepared to endure financial deprivation. And so some could begin to consider it as time goes alongside.”
‘Individuals begin believing it’
Fadden says governments and intelligence businesses have realized the exhausting manner of the facility of disinformation and propaganda channelled by social media.
“You retain repeating issues usually sufficient, individuals begin believing it,” he mentioned. “If it continues down this path for years, just about anyone will be worn down.”
Along with sending politicians to barter with counterparts in Washington, says Fadden, “we have to discover a strategy to play again on the data entrance.”
He says meaning discovering methods “to make use of social media extra successfully than I consider we now have been doing.”
Bisson says authorities help for these affected by tariffs may blunt the influence of such propaganda.
“That is the Canadian authorities making an attempt to shore up that political opinion inside their very own citizenship to say, ‘OK we have this lined, we will handle you it doesn’t matter what,'” he mentioned.
“As a result of if that wasn’t achieved and issues have been beginning to destabilize economically, that may give individuals much more purpose to fall again on considering, nicely, perhaps it is a greater concept if we have simply succumbed to this.”
‘Tripwires’ for spies
The intelligence professionals say it is potential that the U.S. authorities would use extra intrusive ways, comparable to fomenting or financing pro-annexationist teams inside Canada to create the impression of a groundswell of help for the thought.
“They’ve a unprecedented capability to do that,” mentioned Fadden. “The true subject to me is whether or not in respect of Canada, they’ll really make use of these capabilities and assets.”
He says Canada ought to be looking out. “We have to begin on the fundamentals. We have to begin monitoring cash flows. We have to begin speaking about whether or not they’re making an attempt to intervene with our elections in any respect ranges.”
However he says covert operations on Canadian soil would possible provide the U.S. little return in change for quite a lot of danger. And Trump is often his personal messenger, preferring the megaphone to the coded message.
“I’d argue that the present president’s method is more likely to be as efficient as utilizing the comparatively secret assets of the CIA or the U.S. intelligence neighborhood,” Fadden mentioned.
The previous spy chiefs say U.S. intelligence businesses have not often operated in Canada prior to now, and would wish time to develop networks. It could be tough for them to get very far with out alerting the Canadians to their presence, mentioned Elcock.
“Intelligence organizations are out searching for potential threats on a regular basis,” he mentioned, and have intelligence “tripwires” set as much as assist monitor the menace surroundings.
“The chance that the Individuals would run afoul of one thing, like of a tripwire in some unspecified time in the future or speak to someone who then would report it — these issues are extremely possible,” he mentioned.
Purges at businesses
Intelligence professionals who spoke to CBC Information all mentioned that they put some religion within the professionalism of their U.S. counterparts, and their historic attachments to alliances comparable to 5 Eyes and NATO.
Elcock mentioned U.S. businesses must fear about their very own individuals speaking.
“There’s a lengthy relationship between Canada and the USA and there’ll nonetheless be individuals round who wouldn’t essentially approve. So I do not assume they might with any certainty perform one thing like that — that wasn’t a really, very carefully held operation,” he mentioned.
However these calculations may change if the Trump administration continues to take away and exchange personnel within the businesses right down to the managerial and operational stage.
“The extra you get individuals who purchase into the present U.S. president’s philosophy of life,” mentioned Fadden, “the extra he shifts professionals out of the intelligence neighborhood and places his personal individuals in, the extra worrisome it turns into.”
As for these Canadians who wish to see their nation annexed, and have loudly made that case, Elcock says not all ought to essentially be seen as a safety menace.
“It could rely upon what their actions have been. There are many individuals who have bizarre concepts in Canada who do not qualify as a menace to the safety of Canada,” he mentioned. “Lots of these organizations would already be on the radar. So the fact is, in the event that they begin to turn into lively, it isn’t going to be one thing no person’s conscious of.”
The consultants all mentioned that Canada is a way more resilient goal than different international locations the place the U.S. is known to have conducted destabilization operations, however that does not imply it’s proof against stress.
“We have to fear extra and speak extra concerning the medium and long run, somewhat than simply worrying concerning the critically vital tariffs which can be there now,” mentioned Fadden.
He warned if Canada is subjected to a chronic marketing campaign of financial warfare, then “in some unspecified time in the future someone’s going to need to cry uncle.”
Whereas Fadden would not see a navy invasion on the horizon, he mentioned “financial and cultural management of the nation will be simply as efficient.”
