Syria’s leaders say their jihadism is in the past

Final week, whereas touring Damascus, Syria’s new chief Ahmed al-Sharaa (previously generally known as Abu Mohammed al-Jolani) was approached by a younger lady who requested for a photograph with him. He gently requested that she cowl her hair earlier than taking the image.

The incident shortly sparked heated debate throughout Arabic social and mainstream media.

What occurred might have been small however it was telling as a result of it encapsulated the tightrope that Syria’s new rulers Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) – who’re designated as a terrorist organisation by the UN, US, EU and UK – should stroll.

On one facet is the varied, and, in some circumstances extra liberal, Syrian inhabitants, together with the worldwide neighborhood, whose acceptance is essential for HTS’s survival and legitimacy. To them, the hair protecting incident supplied a troubling glimpse into Syria’s potential future underneath HTS, expressing fears that conservative insurance policies may finally mandate the veil for all girls.

On the opposite facet, Islamist hardliners criticised al-Sharaa for taking the photograph in any respect, describing the lady as a “mutabarijah” – a time period for a girl perceived to decorate immodestly or put on make-up – and insisting his motion violated spiritual guidelines.

These hardliners maintain vital sway over militant factions and will rally opposition inside al-Sharaa’s personal Islamist base.

HTS faces the challenge of trying to reconcile these competing calls for – balancing the expectations of the worldwide neighborhood and the liberal elements of Syria’s inhabitants with the calls for of the hardline base. Either side are carefully scrutinising HTS’s each assertion and motion.

The group’s potential to navigate these tensions will likely be crucial to sustaining management and pursuing its political ambitions.

In his messages, he has centered on coexistence inside Syria’s numerous society, granted amnesty to former army conscripts, prohibited acts of vigilante revenge towards ex-government personnel and loyalists, and adopted impartial and at occasions conciliatory language when addressing conventional adversaries, together with Israel, the US, Iran and Russia.

His statements have been intentionally devoid of inflammatory rhetoric or threats, as an alternative centring on themes of reconciliation, stability, and reconstruction, in a transparent effort to neutralise opposition and push for the elimination of HTS and al-Sharaa himself from international terror lists.

It’s nonetheless unclear whether or not al-Sharaa’s versatile method represents a real ideological shift or a calculated technique aimed toward profitable approval and consolidating energy earlier than probably implementing a stricter and extra religiously conservative agenda.

However already his extra progressive strikes are sparking vital unease amongst hardliners in Syria, who insist on an Islamist authorities rooted in a strict and distinctive Sunni id. Whereas Sunni Arabs are the dominant ethnic and non secular group in Syria, the nation is notably numerous, with a spread of minority teams together with Shia Alawites, of which the ousted president Bashar al-Assad is a member, Kurds, Christians, Druze, Turkmen and Ismailis, along with different small teams.

Even when HTS management is honest in its push for change, the varied vary of Islamist and jihadist factions deeply entrenched in Syria – lots of which performed key roles within the current offensive – are unlikely to tolerate something in need of a strict Islamist system. Ought to HTS deviate from such a path, these factions would possible be ready to resort to armed resistance to implement their imaginative and prescient.

Nonetheless this isn’t a brand new problem for HTS.

For a decade the group, previously generally known as al-Nusra Entrance and with roots in transnational jihadist actions, has been evolving.

HTS transitioned from being a covert offshoot of the ultra-hardline IS round 2011 and 2012, to being affiliated to the comparatively extra versatile al-Qaeda the next yr, and by 2016 to an unbiased faction.

It consolidated its management of Idlib province in north-west Syria in 2017, working a civilian “authorities” within the space purportedly with no lasting jihadist connections or ambitions.

This evolution displays al-Sharaa’s strategic imaginative and prescient and sure incorporates parts of opportunism and pragmatism aimed toward making certain the group’s acceptance and long-term survival. HTS’s technique of signalling that it poses no exterior risk has already borne fruit.

Whereas its former jihadist companions, al-Qaeda and IS, have been closely focused in Syria by the US-led coalition – ensuing within the routine assassination of their leaders, usually in Idlib itself – al-Sharaa has operated with relative freedom.

Regardless of a $10m (£7.8m) US bounty on his head, he has been capable of ceaselessly seem publicly, attending occasions and fascinating with the inhabitants, very like a statesman.

Nonetheless, al-Sharaa’s jihadist critics accuse him of being a manipulative politician, prepared to compromise on key ideological rules to advance his personal profession and safe political positive aspects for HTS, on the expense of different militant teams working within the nation.

HTS solidified its authority in Idlib via a twin technique: profitable the hearts and minds of native populations via providing some type of stability, whereas utilizing drive to stamp out or co-opt rivals and even former allies.

The group moved away from distinctive jihadist rhetoric, preventing for faith, and the institution of Islamic rule (Sharia) in Syria, as a part of a wider interconnected world undertaking. As an alternative, they adopted a extra “revolutionary” and nationalist narrative, specializing in the singular aim of toppling Syria’s president Bashar al-Assad and “liberating” Syria.

The civilian entrance established by HTS in 2017 to manage Idlib was known as the Syrian Salvation Authorities (SSG). The goal was to reveal HTS’s governance capabilities, and bolster its legitimacy. This transfer was possible additionally aimed toward assuaging fears about militants working a province, in search of to distance itself from the brutal picture related to IS’s rule over territories in Syria and Iraq.

The SSG operated as a mini-state, full with a first-rate minister, ministries and native departments managing key sectors reminiscent of training, well being and reconstruction, all whereas adhering to a spiritual council guided by Sharia (Islamic regulation). It additionally established professional-looking army and police academies, ceaselessly showcasing their commencement ceremonies and organising army parades, sometimes attended by al-Sharaa.

The SSG ceaselessly showcased its achievements in reconstruction and repair provision. It usually contrasted these efforts with the dire circumstances and rampant corruption in areas managed by the Syrian authorities or rival insurgent teams. Al-Sharaa even twice attended Idlib’s annual e book honest, giving speeches.

However HTS confronted vital challenges in Idlib, and its rule was removed from clean.

Previous to the 27 November HTS-led insurgent offensive, the group was dogged by anti-HTS protests, significantly concentrating on al-Sharaa’s management. Protesters accused HTS of suppressing dissent via pressured disappearances and imprisonment of opponents and critics.

The group additionally confronted criticism for allegedly colluding with international powers to undermine “the jihad” in Syria. In 2023, it was additional rocked by a scandal involving spies inside its high management, and was accused by hardliners of intentionally avoiding significant fight towards authorities forces to please unnamed international backers.

Throughout such protests, al-Sharaa was ceaselessly likened to Assad, whereas HTS’s safety equipment was in comparison with the “Shabiha”, Assad’s infamous loyalist militia.

Nonetheless, you will need to observe that lots of HTS’s critics, previous and current, and a few of the these imprisoned by the group, have been hardliners actively inciting opposition to HTS’s undertaking in Idlib. Others have been locals and activists who criticised what they described as HTS’s monopolisation of energy and “authoritarian” rule.

Though some locals have voiced complaints about spiritual restrictions in Idlib, as reported by Arab media and NGOs, these grievances haven’t been widespread. This can be resulting from HTS’s relative flexibility and the truth that most residents of the province are conservative Sunni Muslims who could also be typically accepting of the established order.

Certainly, HTS has usually are available in for harsh criticism by hardliners for being too “lenient” and failing to impose strict Sharia guidelines in Idlib.

Al-Sharaa has argued that the imposition of strict guidelines such because the morality police is an outdated thought that always causes extra hurt than good. In April 2023 he stated: “We do not wish to create a hypocritical society that prays after we’re round and does not after we’re gone.” He emphasised that he wished folks to stick to Islamic teachings out of conviction, “not via the stick [force]”.

Regardless of these feedback, the group has usually responded by using strict measures in a transparent effort to appease hardliners – a sample that gives perception into how HTS might reply to such pressures in future.

For instance, regardless of dissolving varied Hisba (morality police) buildings that operated underneath thinly-veiled names and regardless of the vocal objections of al-Sharaa himself, the SSG nonetheless established a “public morality police” underneath its Ministry of Inside in early 2024.

These morality forces regulated retailers, ensured girls wore compliant spiritual clothes and restricted the blending of sexes in public areas.

And some months earlier, the SSG’s Ministry of Training had issued a decree mandating that every one feminine college students and employees put on “unfastened Islamic gown that complies with Sharia”, which incorporates protecting one’s hair and avoiding “trend and traits” deemed “incompatible with our spiritual teachings”. The decree additionally prohibited the blending of sexes in major and secondary colleges.

Till not too long ago, the dominant characteristic of Syria’s opposition teams – whether or not insurgent or jihadist – was disunity and fragmentation, usually marked by bouts of infighting. Armed factions competed over territory, income sources, authority and beliefs.

For years, this persistent disunity, amongst different components, severely hampered their potential to attain victory over Assad.

The recent rebel unity that led to Assad’s downfall stays a comparatively new improvement and will nonetheless show fragile. Additionally, there are inside challenges nonetheless posed by rival factions.

HTS has lengthy had a strained relationship with the opposite main insurgent bloc in Syria, the Turkey-backed Syrian Nationwide Military (SNA). The SNA’s focus through the current offensive has largely aligned with Ankara’s priorities – seizing Kurdish-held areas in northern Syria to remove what Turkey perceives as a Kurdish “risk” alongside its borders.

Whether or not the 2 blocs can agree on the division of the strategic places seized from Kurdish forces – or throughout Syria extra broadly – stays unsure, significantly as HTS continues to push for full unity, clearly underneath its personal management.

IS, which stays lively in Syria via each operatives and sleeper cells, has declared its ongoing jihad within the nation and denounced the HTS-led insurgent authority as “apostates” allegedly dropped at energy by “infidel” forces.

With the management of the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) weakening within the northeast, IS is likely to set its sights on the prisons and camps in Hasaka that maintain IS-linked fighters and their households. A mass launch or escape from these services may considerably bolster IS’s ranks and skill to destabilise Syria.

Since the outbreak of the Syrian civil war in 2011 – and Assad’s brutal crackdown on the rebellion – the nation has attracted a variety of international fighters, clerics and transnational jihadist teams, facilitated by porous borders, significantly by way of Turkey.

To consolidate its management over Idlib, and presumably as a part of offers with international powers to comprise the jihadist risk in northern Syria, HTS crushed some native and international factions and co-opted others, integrating them into its personal buildings, renaming their models to obscure their international origins. These embody smaller factions from Central Asia, the Caucasus (Chechens) and China’s Uighur minority.

Many of those smaller factions, together with unbiased jihadist teams like Ansar al-Islam and Ansar al-Tawhid, actively participated within the newest offensive, which highlights their potential vested curiosity in shaping the way forward for the brand new Syria.

By way of post-Assad messaging, groups like al-Qaeda in addition to extra reasonable Islamist figures and students have reminded HTS about its “obligation” to make sure the set-up of an Islamic system in Syria, distinguished by a powerful Sunni id.

When requested by a CNN correspondent on 6 December whether or not HTS intends to impose an Islamic system, al-Sharaa gave a characteristically evasive response. As an alternative of a direct “sure” or “no”, he acknowledged, “Individuals who worry Islamic governance both have seen incorrect implementations of it or don’t perceive it correctly.”

This fastidiously worded reply recommend that HTS possible plans to implement Islamic governance, however maybe in a extra versatile and nuanced kind.

However already since HTS toppled the Assad authorities, ideological tensions have begun to resurface after the initial euphoria and unified effort to attain a typical aim. On 9 December HTS issued a decree granting amnesty to former army conscripts, however hardliners in Syria denounced the transfer as overly “lenient” and inconsistent with Sharia regulation, going as far as to incite disobedience and name for revenge assaults towards ex-government loyalists, immediately defying the HTS order.

HTS tried to quell the uproar by issuing a press release clarifying that it might pursue former authorities personnel and loyalists implicated in struggle crimes – an obvious try to appease critics. On the similar time, HTS sought to bolster its authority, explicitly vowing to punish anybody who defied its decree by partaking in vigilante revenge.

One other level of competition arose on 16 December when al-Sharaa introduced plans to disband and disarm militant teams and militias within the nation, concentrating weapons within the fingers of the state and the army alone.

Once more, hardliners protested, urging factions to retain their arms. They argued the transfer would consolidate energy underneath HTS, leaving no different teams armed to problem its authority and paving the best way for tyranny.

Additional discontent emerged over HTS’s muted response to repeated Israeli airstrikes in Syria following Assad’s fall. After days of silence, on 14 December al-Sharaa criticised the strikes however acknowledged that his group had no intention of partaking in any new conflicts, emphasising its present deal with rebuilding Syria. He additionally acknowledged that he wouldn’t permit Syria for use as a launchpad for assaults towards Israel.

Some seen this stance as weak and a betrayal of Islamist rules. Their frustration was amplified by al-Qaeda’s current message urging HTS to prioritise the struggle towards Israel and fulfil its “obligation” to defend Palestinians in Gaza.

These tensions recommend that hardliners – each inside HTS ranks and exterior factions – could also be prepared to take up arms towards the group in the event that they understand it as straying too removed from their imaginative and prescient for a brand new spiritual Syria.

Many of those people and factions are deeply invested within the nation and are unlikely to relinquish their ambitions simply. They view Syria, very like Afghanistan underneath the Taliban, as a undertaking for a powerful Sunni Islamic state – one that would wield regional affect whereas serving as a protected haven for persecuted Muslims and jihadist fugitives.

Underneath stress from liberals and hardliners alike, al-Sharaa and HTS are treading a wonderful line in an try to not antagonise both facet an excessive amount of and the necessity for flexibility seems to be key.

Per week in the past the younger lady wanting a photograph was requested to cowl her hair.

This week al-Sharaa was photographed with two British diplomats, one in every of whom was Ann Snow, the UK’s particular consultant for Syria. Her hair was uncovered.

Prime picture credit score: Getty

BBC InDepth is the brand new residence on the web site and app for the perfect evaluation and experience from our high journalists. Underneath a particular new model, we’ll deliver you recent views that problem assumptions, and deep reporting on the largest points that will help you make sense of a posh world. And we’ll be showcasing thought-provoking content material from throughout BBC Sounds and iPlayer too. We’re beginning small however pondering massive, and we wish to know what you suppose – you possibly can ship us your suggestions by clicking on the button under.