As The Beer Retailer places proceed to shut throughout Ontario, grocers are being tasked with gathering empty alcohol bottles and cans — a job many didn’t join.
“The January 1 date could also be rolling alongside for the federal government, but it surely’s not rolling alongside for grocers,” mentioned Canadian Federation of Unbiased Grocers senior vice-president Gary Sands.
The province would require unbiased grocers to gather empties as a part of the Ontario Deposit Return Program (ODRP).
Based on Sands, that call is being met with protest from many who would moderately flip of their license than tackle the additional job.
Foremost issues with gathering empty bottles and cans embrace the chance to meals security, discovering area for the containers and the staffing challenges that include having to scrub and set up empties for decide up.
“Now we have quite a few independents who’ve simply not utilized for licenses due to this requirement … And now we have independents who’ve utilized for licenses then came upon concerning the recycling then mentioned thanks however no thanks,” Sands mentioned.
Among the many unbiased grocers that received’t be concerned within the ODRP is David La Mantia.
His household has been operating La Mantia’s Nation Market Contemporary for many years, and has been promoting liquor on the retailer when the primary part of grocery shops had been in a position to promote beer and wine.
Get weekly well being information
Obtain the newest medical information and well being data delivered to you each Sunday.
“It’s not an enormous revenue merchandise to start with, now we have it right here simply as a draw — it brings visitors into our retailer,” he mentioned. “However the price of not solely accepting the empties however cleansing and sorting make it a lose proposition for us.”
La Mantia’s Nation Market Contemporary has been promoting liquor as a part of the federal government’s program since 2015.
Megan King / International Information
For La Mantia, his precedence is client well being and security — however taking empties doesn’t put that on the forefront.
“Our specialty is contemporary produce, contemporary meat, contemporary baked items,” La Mantia mentioned. “I believe as a client you don’t need to assume that you just’re placing your bundle of contemporary strawberries on our checkout belt after anyone has simply positioned a bunch of empty beer bottles or beer cans on that very same checkout belt.”
At a press convention on Monday, Premier Doug Ford was requested about another resolution to grocers gathering empties and mentioned he’s engaged on an answer.
“, it’s ironic. All these retailors, all of them need the booze within the shops, all of them need to promote the booze, however they don’t need to take bottles again,” Ford mentioned. “There’s alternatives too to open new companies to gather the bottles as properly.”
La Mantia has had a contract in place for years concerning promoting liquor in his retailer — which by no means talked about needing to gather empties.
International Information seen the contract and might affirm that there isn’t a reference to that job as a part of the deal.
“We signed a contract in 2019 that has a ten-year time period and it was signed by the chairman of the LCBO, it’s on a kind that they ready,” mentioned La Mantia. “It didn’t require us to take empties, so for the federal government to say we knew what we had been stepping into is totally a falsehood.”
He and different unbiased grocers wish to see that deal — which was signed in good religion — honoured.
“In my mind-set, there must be an industry-wide resolution as an alternative of inserting all of the burden on unbiased grocers and chain grocery shops,” La Mantia mentioned.
He desires to see the burden unfold throughout the entire retail alcohol distribution channel — which embrace LCBO retail shops in addition to unbiased and chain comfort shops.
An e mail response from the Ministry of Finance reads that its laws “embrace the pliability for companies to barter and produce alternate preparations to ship this program, according to the aggressive market we’re opening up. Choices embrace with the ability to be part of collectively for the method or utilizing various places for empty decide up and drop off.”
If the requirement to gather empties stays come January 1, Sands confirms that many grocers will probably be giving up their license
© 2025 International Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.
