North and South Korea are in an underground war

Listen to Jean read this article

The border between North and South Korea is swamped with layers of dense barbed-wire fencing and a whole bunch of guard posts. However dotted amongst them is one thing much more uncommon: large, inexperienced camouflaged audio system.

As I stood wanting into the North one afternoon final month, one of many audio system started blasting South Korean pop songs interspersed with subversive messages. “After we journey overseas, it energises us”, a girl’s voice boomed out throughout the border – an apparent slight given North Koreans usually are not allowed to go away the nation.

From the North Korean facet, I may faintly hear army propaganda music, as its regime tried to drown out the inflammatory broadcasts.

North and South Korea are technically nonetheless at struggle, and though it has been years since both facet shelled the opposite, the 2 sides are combating on a extra refined entrance: a struggle of data.

The South tries to get data into the North, and North Korea’s chief Kim Jong Un tries furiously to dam it, as he makes an attempt to defend his individuals from outdoors data.

North Korea is the one nation on the earth the web has not penetrated. All TV channels, radio stations and newspapers are run by the state.

“The explanation for this management is that a lot of the mythology across the Kim household is made up. Quite a lot of what they inform individuals is lies,” says Martyn Williams, a senior fellow on the Washington-based Stimson Heart, and an knowledgeable in North Korean expertise and data.

Expose these lies to sufficient individuals and the regime may come crumbling down, is how the considering in South Korea goes.

The loudspeakers are one device utilized by the South Korean authorities, however behind the scenes a extra subtle underground motion has flourished.

A small variety of broadcasters and non-profit organisations transmit data into the nation at midnight on quick and medium radio waves, so North Koreans can tune in to hear in secret.

1000’s of USB sticks and micro-SD playing cards are additionally smuggled over the border each month loaded with international data – amongst them, South Korean movies, TV dramas, and pop songs, in addition to information, all designed to problem North Korean propaganda.

However now these working within the discipline worry that North Korea is gaining the higher hand.

Not solely is Kim cracking down arduous on these caught with international content material, however the way forward for this work could possibly be in jeopardy. A lot of it’s funded by the US authorities, and has been hit by US President Donald Trump’s current assist cuts.

So the place does this depart each side of their longstanding data struggle?

Each month, a staff at Unification Media Group (UMG), a South Korean non-profit organisation, sift by way of the newest information and leisure choices to place collectively playlists that they hope will resonate with these within the North.

They then load them onto units, that are categorised in line with how dangerous they’re to view. On low-risk USBs are South Korean TV dramas and pop songs – not too long ago they included a Netflix romance collection When Life Give You Tangerines, and a success from fashionable South Korean singer and rapper Jennie.

Excessive-risk choices embrace what the staff calls “schooling programmes” – data to show North Koreans about democracy and human rights, the content material Kim is assumed to worry essentially the most.

The drives are then despatched to the Chinese language border, the place UMG’s trusted companions carry them throughout the river into North Korea at enormous threat.

South Korean TV dramas could appear innocuous, however they reveal a lot about extraordinary life there – individuals dwelling in high-rise flats, driving quick vehicles and consuming at upmarket eating places. It highlights each their freedom and the way North Korea is a few years behind.

This challenges considered one of Kim’s largest fabrications: that these within the South are poor and miserably oppressed.

“Some [people] inform us they cried whereas watching these dramas, and that they made them take into consideration their very own goals for the very first time”, says Lee Kwang-baek, director of UMG.

It’s troublesome to know precisely how many individuals entry the USBs, however testimonies from current defectors appear to counsel the data is spreading and having an impression.

“Most up-to-date North Korean defectors and refugees say it was international content material that motivated them to threat their lives to flee”, says Sokeel Park, whose organisation Liberty in North Korea works to distribute this content material.

There is no such thing as a political opposition or recognized dissidents in North Korea, and gathering to protest is simply too harmful – however Mr Park hopes some can be impressed to hold out particular person acts of resistance.

Kang Gyuri, who’s 24, grew up in North Korea, the place she ran a fishing enterprise. Then in late 2023, she fled to South Korea by boat.

Watching international TV reveals partly impressed her to go, she says. “I felt so suffocated, and I all of the sudden had an urge to leave.“

After we met in a park on a sunny afternoon in Seoul final month, she reminisced about listening to radio broadcasts along with her mum as a toddler. She obtained maintain of her first Ok-drama when she was 10. Years later she learnt that USB sticks and SD playing cards have been being smuggled into the nation inside bins of fruit.

The extra she watched, the extra she realised the federal government was mendacity to her. “I used to suppose it was regular that the state restricted us a lot. I believed different nations lived with this management,” she explains. “However then I realised it was solely in North Korea.”

Virtually everybody she knew there watched South Korean TV reveals and movies. She and her mates would swap their USBs.

“We talked concerning the fashionable dramas and actors, and the Ok-pop idols we thought have been good wanting, like sure members of BTS.

“We might additionally speak about how South Korea’s financial system was so developed; we simply could not criticise the North Korean regime outright.”

The reveals additionally influenced how she and her mates talked and dressed, she provides. “North Korea’s youth has modified quickly.”

Kim Jong Un, all too conscious of this threat to his regime, is combating again.

Throughout the pandemic, he constructed new electrical fences alongside the border with China, making it tougher for data to be smuggled in. And new legal guidelines launched from 2020 have elevated the punishments for people who find themselves caught consuming and sharing international media. One acknowledged that those that distribute the content material could possibly be imprisoned or executed.

This has had a chilling impact. “This media was once available for purchase in markets, individuals would overtly promote it, however now you possibly can solely get it from individuals you belief,” says Mr Lee.

After the crackdown started Ms Kang and her mates turned extra cautious too. “We do not discuss to one another about this anymore, except we’re actually shut, and even then we’re far more secretive,” she admits.

She says she is conscious of extra younger individuals being executed for being caught with South Korean content material.

Lately Kim has additionally cracked down on behaviour that could possibly be related to watching Ok-dramas. In 2023 he made it a criminal offense for individuals to make use of South Korean phrases or communicate in a South Korean accent.

Members of ‘youth crackdown squads’, patrol the streets, tasked with monitoring younger individuals’s behaviour. Ms Kang remembers being stopped extra typically, earlier than she escaped, and reprimanded for dressing and styling her hair like a South Korean.

The squads would confiscate her telephone and skim her textual content messages, she provides, to verify she had not used any South Korean phrases.

In late 2024, a North Korean cell phone was smuggled overseas by Day by day NK, (Seoul-based media organisation UMG’s information service).

The telephone had been programmed in order that when a South Korean variant of a phrase is entered, it routinely vanishes, changed with the North Korean equal – an Orwellian transfer.

“Smartphones are actually half and parcel of the way in which North Korea tries to indoctrinate individuals”, says Mr Williams.

Following all these crackdown measures, he believes North Korea is now “beginning to acquire the higher hand” on this data struggle.

Following Donald Trump’s return to the White Home earlier this 12 months, funds have been severed to quite a few of assist organisations, together with some working to tell North Koreans. He additionally suspended funds to 2 federally financed information companies, Radio Free Asia and Voice of America (VOA), which had been broadcasting nightly into North Korea.

Trump accused VOA of being “radical” and anti-Trump”, whereas the White Home mentioned the transfer would “guarantee taxpayers are now not on the hook for radical propaganda”.

However Steve Herman, a former VOA bureau chief based mostly in Seoul, argues: “This was one of many only a few home windows into the world the North Korean individuals had, and it has gone silent with no clarification.”

UMG continues to be ready to search out out whether or not their funding can be completely lower.

Mr Park from Liberty in North Korea argues Trump has “by the way” given Kim a serving to hand, and calls the transfer “short-sighted”.

He argues that North Korea, with its increasing assortment of nuclear weapons, poses a significant safety risk – and that given sanctions, diplomacy and army strain have did not persuade Kim to denuclearise, data is one of the best remaining weapon.

“We’re not simply making an attempt to include the specter of North Korea, we’re making an attempt to unravel it,” he argues. “To do this you should change the character of the nation.

“If I used to be an American common I might be saying ‘how a lot does these items price, and really that is a fairly good use of our sources'”.

The query that is still is, who ought to fund this work. Some query why it has fallen virtually totally to the US.

One resolution could possibly be for South Korea to foot the invoice – however the subject of North Korea is closely politicised right here.

The liberal opposition get together tends to attempt to enhance relations with Pyongyang, which means funding data warfare is a no go. The get together’s frontrunner in subsequent week’s presidential election has already indicated he would flip off the loudspeakers if elected.

But Mr Park stays hopeful. “The great factor is that the North Korean authorities cannot go into individuals’s heads and take out the data that is been constructing for years,” he factors out.

And as applied sciences develop, he’s assured that spreading data will get simpler. “In the long term I actually imagine that is going to be the factor that adjustments North Korea”.

Prime picture credit score: Getty

BBC InDepth is the house on the web site and app for one of the best evaluation, with contemporary views that problem assumptions and deep reporting on the largest problems with the day. And we showcase thought-provoking content material from throughout BBC Sounds and iPlayer too. You possibly can ship us your suggestions on the InDepth part by clicking on the button under.