Greater than 7,300 Afghans are anticipated to be resettled within the UK on account of a significant authorities knowledge breach, based on a Nationwide Audit Workplace report that raises doubts over officers’ claims of a £850m value.
The accidental leak by an MoD official in 2022 of 18,700 Afghans’ particulars who had labored with or for the British authorities led to the opening of a new route by which these endangered might search relocation to the UK from their house nation.
The MoD expects 7,355 folks to be resettled via the Afghanistan response route (ARR) as a direct results of the breach, together with the relations of these immediately affected, the NAO mentioned.
The watchdog mentioned the federal government was unable to calculate the precise value of its response. The £850m estimate didn’t embody authorized prices or compensation claims, and doubts had been raised by the NAO concerning the “completeness and accuracy” of the bottom determine.
The NAO mentioned: “The MoD estimates that, as of July 2025, the federal government had spent round £400m on resettling folks via the ARR and that it could spend round an additional £450m on the scheme.
“The MoD estimated the prices to the entire of presidency to be £128,000 per resettled particular person, of which an estimated £53,000 can be met by the MoD. On the time of publication, the MoD had not supplied us with adequate proof to offer us confidence relating to the completeness and accuracy of those estimates.”
The spreadsheet by chance shared by the MoD comprised 33,345 strains of information containing the names and call particulars of candidates and, in some cases, info regarding the candidates’ relations.
The NAO mentioned the MoD didn’t document precisely how a lot it had spent on resettling folks via the ARR scheme as a result of it didn’t individually determine these prices in its accounting system.
The federal government mentioned it did this to keep up the secrecy of the ARR scheme whereas a superinjunction was in place stopping disclosure of each the info breach and the existence of the injunction itself.
After the invention of the info breach on 25 August 2023, the MoD had utilized to the excessive courtroom for an injunction to stop the info loss changing into public. Seven days later, the courtroom granted a superinjunction – which additionally prevented disclosure of the existence of the injunction itself, when a choose accepted the MoD’s evaluation of threat to the security and lives of many people and their households.
after publication promotion
A subsequent overview in January 2025 prompt that the associated fee and scale of opening the brand new route for relocation was not proportionate to the extra threat to these whose knowledge had been breached. The defence secretary, John Healey, closed the ARR and the injunction on reporting was dropped in July.
Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, the chair of the cross-party public accounts committee, mentioned: “After the excessive courtroom superinjunction was lifted earlier this 12 months, confusion nonetheless stays over the reported £850m historic and future prices regarding the breach, with the MoD unable to supply adequate assurance over their numbers.
“This determine doesn’t embody all authorized prices or compensation claims, which at the moment stay unknown. The PAC will probably be analyzing these points in our inquiry subsequent week and I will probably be following developments intently because the NAO conducts additional work to supply transparency on the figures of their upcoming report on Afghan resettlement schemes, with lots of these needing relocation but to reach within the UK.”
