As extra main meals manufacturers decide to phasing out chemical dyes from snacks and cereals within the U.S., some are struggling to search out pure replacements. Many shoppers say they need shiny colours.
SCOTT SIMON, HOST:
How colourful do we actually need our meals to be? This query’s on the agenda of main manufacturers this yr as extra of them decide to phasing out chemical dyes from snacks and cereals within the U.S. NPR’s Alina Selyukh reviews that is been a debate for many years.
ALINA SELYUKH, BYLINE: The story that at all times comes up is in regards to the cereal Trix.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED REPORTER: This morning, a giant announcement from a cereal big.
UNIDENTIFIED ACTORS: (As characters) Foolish rabbit, Trix are for youths.
SELYUKH: Ten years in the past, Normal Mills made a splash saying it will take away synthetic dyes from cereal, and it launched Trix coloured naturally with vegetables and fruit. And many consumers hated it. They complained on social media and the information that the brand new Trix regarded unhappy and boring. And Normal Mills capitulated.
THOMAS GALLIGAN: They really put the meals dyes, the artificial dyes, again into the Trix cereal formulation.
SELYUKH: Thomas Galligan is with the Middle for Science within the Public Curiosity. It advocates towards artificial dyes over well being issues, notably in youngsters.
GALLIGAN: And that is actually an issue as a result of Normal Mills framed this as a shopper demand situation – that is what shoppers need.
SELYUKH: And it set the tone. So when Kellogg later dyed Froot Loops with spices and juices, it was for Canada however not the U.S. M&M’s maker Mars phased out synthetic colours in Europe however not the U.S. The all-American Kraft Mac & Cheese eliminated chemical dyes stealthily. It is nonetheless neon yellow however naturally, boasting within the advertisements…
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #1: (As character) Mothers did not discover. Children did not discover. (Laughter) Neither did canines.
SELYUKH: Kellogg and Mars would say, People actually love shiny colours, and information recommend it is true.
MARION NESTLE: Individuals suppose meals tastes higher if it is brightly coloured – interval, finish of story.
SELYUKH: Marion Nestle is a public well being nutritionist who’s tracked analysis on meals dyes.
NESTLE: Brighter colours are perceived as tasting higher, whether or not the style adjustments or not.
SELYUKH: However is it our nature, or is it advertising? Take into consideration your power of behavior, particularly for childhood snacks. In fact, youngsters have a tendency to like brighter colours, so that they get marketed to.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED ACTORS: (As characters) Wow, blue Froot Loops.
SELYUKH: And once they develop up, it is onerous to let go of that reminiscence.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED ACTORS: (As characters) We like them, Toucan Sam
SELYUKH: Meals dyeing goes again centuries. Suppose dairy farmers including spices to make cheese look extra yellow. Meals historian Ai Hisano says railroads made an influence. When Florida farmers needed to compete with California farmers, they began dyeing their oranges to be extra orange. Alongside got here processed meals. When butter needed to compete with margarine, it grew to become a richer yellow. Over time, Hisano says colourful promoting and the trendy grocery store educated us what to anticipate.
AI HISANO: Like, say, strawberry candies or strawberry drinks. They do not appear to be an actual strawberry colour, however folks – we are able to be taught to know.
SELYUKH: And be taught to acknowledge even science-fictiony flavors and colours, like blue raspberry.
Now we’re at a brand new turning level. The Trump administration’s well being secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., is pushing corporations to do away with artificial dyes, and main manufacturers are agreeing. Even M&M’s is as soon as once more keen to attempt a naturally coloured model. The irony is that with out synthetic colour, many snacks and cereals look – properly, clearly processed. And pure dyes may be finicky.
NICK SCHEIDLER: Coloration has been a problem for us.
SELYUKH: Nick Scheidler leads product improvement at Walmart’s Sam’s Membership, which in 2022 pledged that by the tip of this yr, it will take away dozens of components from its non-public model Member’s Mark. That features high-fructose corn syrup, some preservatives and synthetic dyes. The latter proved the trickiest.
SCHEIDLER: Yeah. So a number of the issues we noticed have been the colours truly have been muted, they usually obtained repeatedly lighter over time.
SELYUKH: Some replacements are tried and true. Turmeric makes issues yellow, beets purple, a seed referred to as annatto orange, and blue can come from spirulina, which is an algae. However then you definately add these savory dyes to sweets and you have to discover a method to masks their flavors.
SCHEIDLER: In some instances, too, it wasn’t holding the colour as lengthy.
SELYUKH: Scheidler says the ultimate frontiers for his crew – one is sports activities drinks in colours to rival Gatorade. The opposite is icing for cupcakes and cookies – shiny like crayons. And I stored questioning, why hassle? Why cannot cupcakes simply be much less vivid? Scheidler says Sam’s Membership stored asking its buyers about this.
SCHEIDLER: The visible look continues to be one thing crucial that they’ve instructed us.
SELYUKH: Nature or nurture, buyers mentioned they didn’t desire a grey, murky soda or a dusty-looking candy deal with.
Alina Selyukh, NPR Information.
Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional data.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts could range. Transcript textual content could also be revised to appropriate errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its unique broadcast or publication. The authoritative document of NPR’s programming is the audio document.
