Article Abstract
- The 7th Circuit Courtroom of Appeals declined to overturn Cook dinner County’s assault weapons ban in June.
- Two gun rights teams are interesting that call to the U.S. Supreme Courtroom.
- They hope the courtroom guidelines of their favor and that the choice will overturn comparable bans throughout the U.S.
- Illinois enacted a statewide ban in 2023 that can also be being challenged within the courts.
This abstract was written by the reporters and editors who labored on this story.
Two nationwide gun rights organizations are asking the U.S. Supreme Courtroom to strike down Cook dinner County’s ban on assault-style weapons in hopes that such a call would overturn comparable bans nationally, together with the statewide ban Illinois lawmakers enacted in 2023.
The Firearms Coverage Coalition and the Second Modification Basis filed a petition with the courtroom Wednesday, asking it to reverse the 7th Circuit Courtroom of Appeals. In June, the 7th Circuit mentioned plaintiffs within the case had proven no purpose for the courtroom to reverse its personal precedents which have upheld assault weapons bans, together with a 2019 decision upholding the Cook dinner County legislation.
The petition was filed on the identical day two youngsters have been killed and 17 different people have been injured in a mass shooting at a Catholic church in Minneapolis. As of Thursday, authorities had not but publicly recognized the particular weapons utilized in that capturing, solely to say certainly one of them was a rifle.
It additionally got here because the 7th Circuit remains to be weighing arguments in a problem to Illinois’ statewide assault weapons ban, often known as the Shield Illinois Communities Act. Illinois Lawyer Normal Kwame Raoul’s workplace filed its remaining transient in that attraction Aug. 14. The courtroom has not but set a date for oral arguments.
“The AR-15 is the most well-liked rifle in America, owned by tens of millions of peaceful folks for lawful functions day-after-day,” Coalition President Brandon Combs mentioned in a press release. “The Invoice of Rights just isn’t a suggestion, and the Second Modification just isn’t a second-class proper.”
Cook dinner County’s Ban
Cook dinner County first adopted a neighborhood assault weapons ban in 1993, and it has been up to date no less than twice since then. It’s now formally often known as the Blair Holt Assault Weapons Ban, named after a Chicago teen who was killed in a 2007 capturing whereas defending a highschool classmate.
The legislation prohibits the possession, acquisition and switch of quite a lot of firearms, together with semiautomatic rifles that may settle for large-capacity magazines. It particularly names 125 prohibited rifles, together with the AR-15.
In 2018, a federal decide in Chicago upheld the legislation, citing a 7th Circuit determination from three years earlier upholding an almost an identical metropolis ordinance in Highland Park. The case was appealed and in 2019, and the 7th Circuit reaffirmed its place that “bans on assault weapons and large-capacity magazines don’t contravene the Second Modification.”
The U.S. Supreme Courtroom declined to hear an attraction of that call.
The present problem was filed in 2021, when the 2 gun rights organizations went again to courtroom searching for to have each the Highland Park and Cook dinner County selections reversed. The plaintiffs embody two Cook dinner County residents, Cutberto Viramontes and Christopher Khaya.
Latest selections
Whereas that case was continuing by courtroom, the U.S. Supreme Courtroom handed down a landmark gun rights determination in 2022, New York State Rifle and Pistol Assoc. v. Bruen. That ruling held that to move constitutional muster, gun management legal guidelines have to be “in line with the Nation’s historic custom of firearm regulation.”
Additionally whereas the case was pending, the Illinois Normal Meeting handed a statewide assault weapons ban, formally often known as the Protect Illinois Communities Act.
In November 2023, the 7th Circuit issued a ruling in a consolidated attraction involving the statewide ban in addition to native bans in Chicago, Naperville and Cook dinner County. In that ruling, the courtroom refused to challenge preliminary injunctions to dam enforcement of any of these legal guidelines, saying its unique ruling upholding the Highland Park ordinance nonetheless stood.
Because of this, in March 2024, U.S. District Choose Rebecca Pallmeyer granted Cook dinner County’s movement to dismiss the lawsuit.
The plaintiffs appealed that ruling to the 7th Circuit, hoping for a reversal of the appellate courtroom’s earlier selections. However in a easy three-page opinion June 2, a three-judge panel mentioned the plaintiffs had supplied no compelling purpose for the courtroom to rethink its earlier selections.
Now, the plaintiffs are asking the U.S. Supreme Courtroom to reverse the 7th Circuit. However in latest months, the nation’s excessive courtroom has been reluctant to take up the query of assault weapon bans.
In July 2024, the courtroom declined to hear an appeal of the 7th Circuit’s determination to not challenge preliminary injunctions on the state and native assault weapons bans. And in June, the courtroom also declined to listen to appeals involving Maryland’s assault weapons ban in addition to Rhode Island’s ban on large-capacity magazines.
In denying to listen to the Maryland and Rhode Island appeals, nevertheless, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote in a statement that he felt the difficulty of assault weapons was not but ripe for assessment, however that the courtroom most likely would handle it “within the subsequent Time period or two.” He additionally particularly cited the Cook dinner County case as certainly one of a number of that the courtroom may resolve to assessment.
Capitol News Illinois is a nonprofit, nonpartisan information service that distributes state authorities protection to tons of of reports retailers statewide. It’s funded primarily by the Illinois Press Basis and the Robert R. McCormick Basis.
