A silver Toyota minivan pulls right into a financial institution car parking zone in Toronto’s west finish.
Two younger Punjabi males step out and begin trying round for his or her consumer, a girl they’ve been speaking with over the earlier days by way of texts and calls.
She has agreed to pay them $4,000 to be smuggled south throughout the border into the US.
The 2 males imagine the lady is ready for them contained in the financial institution.
Talking Punjabi, they message and name her, asking her to return exterior and be part of them within the automotive to start the journey.
However in actuality, there is no such thing as a girl ready within the financial institution.
As a substitute, reporters from the
Investigative Journalism Bureau
(IJB) are observing the scene as a part of a months-long investigation right into a burgeoning trade of underground human smuggling networks.
The networks overtly promote two important companies on main social media platforms: human smuggling in each instructions throughout the Canada-United States border, and promoting apparently bogus, or falsely obtained, immigration visas for Canada at road costs of as much as $40,000.
Regardless of the federal authorities’s
$1.3-billion investment in tighter border security
— which features a devoted border czar, 24/7 surveillance, drones and Black Hawk helicopters — entrepreneurial smugglers and visa sellers proceed to bypass Canadian immigration legal guidelines.
The variety of human smuggling instances opened by the Canada Border Providers Company (CBSA) is about to hit a file excessive over the earlier 5 years. CBSA information reveals it opened 70 instances linked to human smuggling as of mid-August, a median of almost 10 a month in comparison with solely 2.5 a month in 2021. That’s a 280 per cent improve.
Asylum claims surged by 523 per cent between January and July this 12 months at a border crossing south of Montreal — the identical space the place on-line smuggling advertisers informed IJB reporters they might safely transport shoppers south throughout the border.
U.S. Lawyer Common Pam Bondi not too long ago mentioned smuggling has “gotten a lot worse” on the Canadian border.
A minimum of a part of this site visitors could also be attributable to the actions of on-line criminals.
The imagery posted of a few of the accounts linked to the smuggling and visa adverts typically characteristic Indian males posing in Ontario-plated vehicles. In some pictures, they’re holding handguns and rifles. One video posted by an individual linked to a variety of on-line accounts reveals a person cocking a pistol in a automotive. Utilizing landmarks, reporters geolocated the video to a strip mall in Brampton.
In a press release, the CBSA mentioned it was “conscious of the presence of worldwide organized crime teams in Canada and is all the time working to forestall and disrupt their Canadian operations… Prison organizations search to revenue from the desperation and vulnerability of others, typically together with folks affected by geopolitics and worldwide conflicts or crises.”
Reporters gathered and analyzed lots of of Instagram adverts pitching covert passage throughout the Canada-U.S. border by land. “Montreal to New York protected attain, no police,” reads one put up.
The IJB responded to one in every of these adverts to rearrange the assembly within the financial institution car parking zone.
Different adverts additionally characteristic the promise of entry to Canada by air, principally from India, with the assistance of visas and direct flights. Some accounts promote each companies.
“Canadian enterprise visa inside 15 days DM (direct message) for extra data,” says one advert displaying a would-be letter from the Canadian authorities relating to a residency utility.
Journey paperwork have been supplied on the market for years on harder-to-access channels just like the darkish net. Now, these paperwork have grow to be broadly obtainable on the most important social media platforms, reaching an infinite potential market.
A few of these adverts garner lots of of 1000’s of views, and a few accounts have existed for almost two years.
An announcement from Meta, which owns Instagram, says “we prohibit human smuggling content material or companies on our platforms, and we take away such content material after we discover it.”
The corporate took down 4 accounts that marketed illicit immigration companies after the IJB shared a choice of posts with the corporate.
“On this case, our groups reviewed and eliminated the content material and accounts that violated our human smuggling insurance policies,” a spokesperson mentioned. “That is an adversarial house with teams always evolving their strategies to evade detection, and regardless of our ongoing investments, we all know that there can be examples of issues we miss or we take down in error.”
The CBSA mentioned it’s “conscious that some travellers could try to make use of fraudulent or fraudulently-obtained documentation to realize entry to Canada. CBSA officers are educated in interview, examination, and investigative strategies – together with on find out how to determine fraudulent paperwork.”
The assertion additionally says the RCMP is chargeable for implementing the regulation at unlawful entry factors.
In a press release, the RCMP mentioned it “is dedicated to disrupting unlawful human smuggling, together with the rising menace of on-line commercials… We’re actively concentrating on people and networks taking advantage of on-line commercials promising the protected passage of unlawful migrants into Canada or out of Canada.”
However federal companies at the moment face long-shot odds making an attempt to cease unlawful immigration schemes concentrating on Canada, say some safety consultants.
Relating to refined and arranged unlawful immigration operations, “the chances are fairly good that, more often than not, they’re going to get their approach with it,” mentioned Arne Kislenko, a nationwide safety professional and former senior immigration officer at Toronto’s Pearson Worldwide Airport all through the Nineteen Nineties.
“They’re normally forward of the curve…. that means that they’re normally well-aware of coverage modifications that normally have an awesome potential to adapt, whether or not it’s technically or operationally…They all the time appear to be one step forward of you.”
The smugglers
To make contact with these breaching Canada’s borders, IJB reporters created faux social media accounts to discover on-line pages the place illicit companies are supplied. Shortly, 1000’s of posts had been discovered, with some even showing as paid commercials on Instagram.
Posing as potential shoppers, reporters contacted folks promoting each border smuggling and visa companies to study their enterprise fashions, pricing and strategies. Reporters discovered a community of typically interconnected accounts that provide comparable companies.
Turning into a consumer of a border smuggler was straightforward: reporters merely texted a telephone quantity marketed in a social media put up. Lots of the posts present testimonies from individuals who declare to have crossed the border safely and shortly in each instructions.
The textual content messages typically moved to telephone calls, as reporters spoke with a number of completely different suppliers of smuggling companies and visa choices over two months. Most of these conversations had been in Punjabi, the language primarily spoken in India’s Punjab area. Some had been in English.
Smugglers who take folks by land throughout the U.S.-Canada border usually quoted charges of round $4,000 for protected and undetected passage, through crossings in Montreal and northern New York.
Within the case of the Toronto financial institution car parking zone encounter, arranging the assembly concerned speaking with smugglers who had completely different telephone numbers with space codes in British Columbia, Toronto and South Carolina.
They promised they might drive the lady to Montreal and information her illicitly throughout the border into New York state. In her case, cost was to be made through financial institution switch from contained in the automotive. The lads even supplied to attach the lady with a contact in New York to get her a job.
“I’ve booked a shared trip to Montreal, okay,” one message learn, indicating different shoppers would be part of the identical trip.
“Be prepared within the morning, sister.”
After the automotive arrived within the car parking zone, reporters covertly photographed two males who repeatedly bought out and in on the lookout for the lady.
“The place are you at? The motive force is at your location,” messaged a smuggler, suggesting that they had been a dispatcher who was not on the scene however who despatched the drivers to the pickup.
The automotive is registered to a person with a house handle in Hamilton.
After a couple of minutes, reporters ended the interplay.
“Scared, cancelling plans,” reporters responded in a textual content message. “Not coming.”
“Sister, why? What occurred? Discuss,” the dispatcher mentioned.
The drivers left 10 minutes later. However the dispatcher stored messaging, asking the lady to rethink
“Decide up the decision.”
In a second state of affairs, an IJB reporter requested to be smuggled in the wrong way — from upstate New York to Canada.
They had been instructed, in Punjabi, to take a bus from Schenectady, New York, to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. From there, an affiliate of the smuggler would decide them up and drive them to the land border. No police could be round to intercept them, they had been assured. The consumer would then be taken to Montreal, the place they might pay the smuggler $4,000 after a protected crossing.
In a 3rd interplay, reporters posing as shoppers organized to be picked up by smugglers at an east-end Toronto mall and pushed to Quebec.
“Montreal to the big apple bro. By automotive. Similar day attain. One hour stroll,” a smuggler messaged, including that “crossing is just attainable on strolling” and {that a} group of 5 shoppers could be guided by the smugglers over the telephone. Reporters had been informed that when in New York, shoppers could be picked up in a automotive and would wish to remain the evening with the U.S.-based smugglers.
Quickly after, reporters had been texted by a smuggler {that a} Volkswagen Jetta was arriving on the rendezvous, the automobile confirmed up on the mall car parking zone. A younger male stepped out and as he regarded round for the consumer, reporters photographed the automotive. Reporters left the scene with out bodily participating with the person, however minutes later, one of many smugglers texted reporters, saying, “Why did you get the photographs of the automotive??? This isn’t good…”
Reporters discovered that the automotive is registered to 2 males who’ve listed residence addresses in Markham.
Crossing the fields
After shoppers share their location through map monitoring apps on their telephone, the smugglers information them to their vacation spot.
“Your community is sweet? for the [live] location,” one message to reporters from a smuggler learn. “2 particular person information you on telephone.”
The smugglers aren’t shy about sharing what they depict as a foolproof methodology.
In a single June 2024 Instagram video, three males carrying backpacks may be seen traversing a discipline close to the Quebec-New York border the place the grass is knee-high. Up forward is the border that these obvious shoppers are about to cross to get into the U.S. The put up is captioned, “Montreal to New York attain 9 June… Contact for more information.”
In one other clip in the identical put up, a smuggler seems to observe the pair’s actions remotely. “Take a left when the bushes finish… go into the sector and take a left to cross,” the smuggler says in Haryanvi, the first language within the Indian state of Haryana.
The IJB verified the sector within the clip is in Covey Hill, Que., about 4 kilometres from the U.S. Customs and Border Safety’s Cannon Corners border entry level. It is usually about 17 kilometres from the Roxham Highway border entry level, which the Canadian and U.S. governments closed in 2023 after a surge in Canada-bound migrant encounters.
One other smuggling advert incorporates a picture of three males in a automotive, captioned with the message “protected attain yesterday no camp no police.”
“No camp” means shoppers gained’t be despatched to a U.S. detention centre, one smuggler defined to reporters posing as a consumer.
Some shoppers who’ve launched into the journey confronted a lot worse than detention. Some in the end didn’t make it, getting injured and even dying on the way in which; two smugglers had been convicted within the deaths of an Indian household of 4 who froze to demise whereas making an attempt to illegally cross into the U.S. from Manitoba throughout blizzard circumstances in 2022.
The stream of unlawful migration within the Quebec border space seems to be regular, regardless of fewer total asylum claims throughout all nationalities being made throughout Canada this 12 months.
In July, an alleged drunk driver in Quebec struck a automobile, which was ferrying round a dozen unlawful migrants into Canada from the U.S. In early August, 44 asylum seekers and three alleged smugglers in a truck had been
close to Stanstead, Que.
In a June 2025 assertion on Countering Migrant Smuggling, the G7 mentioned it could “collaborate with social media corporations to agree on voluntary ideas to forestall organized crime teams from exploiting on-line platforms to promote, coordinate, and facilitate migrant smuggling operations.”
The visa sellers
Along with human smuggling throughout land borders, IJB reporters examined the operations of those that have been providing visas for entry to Canada on social media since at the least 2023.
Immigration consultants who reviewed the findings weren’t capable of affirm whether or not the visas had been cast or real paperwork fraudulently obtained. The costs supplied and the timelines to get the visas, nevertheless, are extremely inconsistent with authorized visa processes.
Quite a few adverts examined by the IJB characteristic several types of Canadian visas stamped inside Indian passports. In a single occasion, a video that includes at the least 25 Indian passports with Canadian visas stamped in them was captioned with, “Canada enterprise visa, positive shot assured. No advance, no embassy charges, no ticket prices, all cost on attain.”
Posted charges for Canadian visas vary from $25,000 to $40,000, full cost of which is to be collected upon arrival in particular person at an airport in Canada with no upfront charge.
Amandeep Singh Dhillon, a registered immigration agent in Ontario, says quite a few travellers arrive in Canada on “actual” visas that had been secured utilizing fraudulent paperwork. Usually, these are procured through unlicensed brokers in India, he mentioned.
“They’d decide anyone in Punjab, a random man doing agriculture,” he mentioned of the consultants. “However then they might make papers saying, you understand, he’s a professor. And they’d have pay stubs, all the pieces, faux financial institution statements. And it could get accredited.
“They’d simply get a aircraft, land in Canada and after that … A few of them would declare asylum immediately (upon) touchdown in Canada. Some would join with the subsequent step (i.e. the smuggler step) after which go to the States.”
The IJB contacted one such visa vendor, who marketed that they might transfer folks between Delhi and Canada. The vendor informed a reporter posing as a consumer that he might organize a direct flight for the consumer from India to Canada in 10 days with “no [real] visa required.” All he’d want was a selfie, a PDF scan of the consumer’s passport, and a cost of $40,000 to be handed over on the Canadian vacation spot airport in particular person.
A short lived resident visa utility usually prices $239.75, in line with Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada. Dhillon mentioned his workplaces charged $500 to $800 for the standard customer visa utility which might be rejected.
Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) lists the processing time for a federal expert employee visa at seven months as of August 29, 2025. That compares to a commonly-advertised timeframe of 15 days within the on-line visa promoting adverts.
Safety consultants who reviewed a sampling of paperwork posted on-line by sellers had been skeptical about their authenticity.
Tony Smith, founding father of U.Ok. border safety agency Fortinus International, reviewed U.Ok. and Canadian visa passport stamps on the IJB’s request.
“That (visa) sticker that’s caught on that passport is a forgery,” mentioned Smith upon viewing an Instagram put up of a visa for the U.Ok. that had been positioned into an Indian passport. Smith, who spent years on the border frontlines, additionally noticed at the least one passport that appeared cast.
Smith says border brokers in Canada will possible spot counterfeit visas and reject the passport holder.
Nevertheless, even when individuals are caught with cast paperwork, they’ll declare asylum, consultants say.
“When you declare asylum, you can’t be eliminated by immigration till your utility has been processed. It’s very possible you’ll be given non permanent admission into the nation pending consideration of your utility, and then you definately’re in,” mentioned Smith.
Kislenko, the previous Canadian immigration officer who now teaches historical past at Toronto Metropolitan College, mentioned claiming asylum “modifications the dynamics of all the pieces. The main target turns into on the legitimacy of that particular person’s [asylum] declare.”
Greater than 30,000 people with failed asylum instances remained needed for elimination proceedings throughout Canada as of July, in line with CBSA information.
Even shoppers beforehand refused or “banned” of their makes an attempt to enter Canada are promised assured entry by the net posters.
“In case you are refused from Canada, banned! Then don’t fear, we’ll ship you to Canada, that too in simply 10 days,” reads one visa advert translated from Punjabi by reporters. One other advert posted June 8, 2025, says individuals who have been “refused and banned” can nonetheless avail of a “direct flight Delhi to Toronto.” The identical account additionally advertises “airport clearance obtainable” for these with research and customer visas at airports in Delhi and Amritsar, one other Indian metropolis.
One advert, which appeared as a sponsored put up featured by Instagram, marketed contract marriages as a method of acquiring authorized standing in Canada. The account, which Instagram really tagged, overtly advertises Canadian visas, too.
With such a deluge of available choices to would-be shoppers on-line — whether or not they be overland border crossers or these coming to Canada by air — authorities face an uphill activity in combating the observe.
Masoud Kianpour, geopolitical analysis fellow at Toronto Metropolitan College, mentioned social media “has grow to be a playground for all kinds of actors, together with those that are false dream sellers…These unlawful actions are being executed on an on a regular basis foundation, and there’s mainly no mechanism to observe and to regulate that.”
Oftentimes, Kianpour mentioned, the criminals are “not even contained in the nation.”
The CBSA, for its half, insists it’s conscious of the difficulty and is working to fight it.
The CBSA’s Daniel Anson says there are greater than 50 liaison officers stationed abroad that, amongst different duties, help airways in “making certain travellers are real travellers and… will not be a nationwide safety or inadmissibility danger to Canada.”
Greater than 11,000 folks had been offloaded from Canada-bound planes final 12 months, he mentioned, including that “a lot of these circumstances are as a result of we recognized that they had fraudulent paperwork, faux visas or fraudulently paying visas.”
The CBSA mentioned its Nationwide Paperwork Centre (NDC), which sends operational bulletins and advisories to frame officers throughout the nation, “issued 17 Company-wide doc alerts in 2024 and 15 in 2025 (as of August 18) to advise frontline officers and airline companions of rising tendencies within the altering and counterfeiting of particular journey doc sorts.”
Antonio Nicaso, an professional on organized crime and professor at Queen’s College, mentioned regulation enforcement in Canada is struggling to maintain up with what he calls “felony Darwinism” – the evolution of crime teams into hybrid organizations which might be extraordinarily nicely expert within the cyber sphere.
“You may’t combat this new kind of organized crime with the normal strategies,” he mentioned, including that regulation enforcement must be hyper-focused on the digital realm in addition to the bodily.
“There is no such thing as a approach you could problem them should you don’t have these particular abilities in regulation enforcement companies,” he mentioned. “For those who don’t adapt and address this new dimension, you can be out of enterprise.”
The Investigative Journalism Bureau (IJB) on the College of Toronto’s Dalla Lana Faculty of Public Well being is a collaborative investigative newsroom supported by Postmedia that companions with teachers, researchers and journalists whereas coaching the subsequent technology of investigative reporters.
Our web site is the place for the most recent breaking information, unique scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and join our newsletters here.
