Editor’s word: The recap beneath incorporates spoilers for Watson Episode 4.
This week’s episode of Watson is the primary to interrupt away from the format established within the first three — not less than that’s the way it initially appears. Episode 4 opens with Dr. Watson (Morris Chesnut) presenting his interns with one other “signal-to-noise” train they’re all thrilled about losing their time on. The train entails them making an attempt to determine if one out of a trio of sufferers that had been lately seen at UHOP has particulars that may be of diagnostic curiosity, and it’s implied that every time they’ve been offered with this train, it’s all noise and no sign.
Whereas Watson worries in regards to the irregular variety of inexperienced markers that he out of the blue has within the workplace, Dr. Lubbock (Inga Schlingmann) is fixated on the tongue of one of many sufferers, William Betancourt. His tongue exhibits indicators that he has Cowden Syndrome, which is a uncommon genetic dysfunction that results in an elevated danger for most cancers. Dr. Lubbock reveals that she noticed the identical papillomatosis on the primary cadaver she reduce open in medical faculty. Dr. Derian (Eve Hole) is instantly dismissive of the thought and spends a lot of the episode making an attempt her damnedest to disprove that anybody might keep in mind their first cadaver vividly sufficient to determine another person’s medical illness. Even the Crofts (Peter Mark Kendall) take part on the ribbing, however this week proves to be one other win for Dr. Lubbock.
William Betancourt is named again into the hospital for extra testing, and he’s reasonably aloof in regards to the seriousness of the matter. He’s “Name Me Invoice,” the billboard lawyer, and his time is cash. He even refuses to go underneath for a colonoscopy, which sadly reveals that he has tumors that have to be operated on instantly. Whereas Invoice is on the desk, he crashes, and so they aren’t in a position to save him. There’s a silver lining to his demise, as their Cowden Syndrome analysis results in his kin getting examined. With the affected person dying earlier than the episode’s title card even seems, it’s clear that this week’s Watson is mixing issues up — and it’s a welcome change of tempo.
Watson’s first three episodes had been fairly lackluster, however Episode 4 is the place issues begin to lastly decide up, notably for Watson’s interns. After last week’s revelation that Dr. Lubbock is faking her engagement, the sequence lastly begins to peel again the layers on her, and surprisingly, it’s all because of Dr. Derian. And, if I’m appropriately choosing up what Watson appears to be placing down with Lubbock and Stephens, we might have one other Angela and Hodgins, however provided that Watson is keen to put money into these characters and make them extra than simply shiny stereotypes.
‘Watson’ Goes Amish in Pursuit of a Thriller Affected person
Invoice’s demise hits Dr. Lubbock onerous, and it makes her take into consideration her cadaver and the way she wished she had identified what she was when he was on her desk. Dr. Watson seizes on the chance and means that they need to work backward to determine who Lubbock’s cadaver was and attempt to contact his subsequent of kin to check them for Cowden Syndrome. Whereas the Crofts dissect Lubbock’s notes from college, she, Dr. Derian, and Dr. Watson head to the morgue to speak with the medical expert, Brenda (Karen Robinson), in hopes that she may know precisely who it was on Lubbock’s desk that day. Brenda isn’t notably thrilled about seeing Lubbock or Derian once more, provided that they each misbehaved in college, however, with a pair of Steeler’s tickets as a bribe, Watson convinces her to provide them entry to the information, and so they scour by way of a whole bunch of potentialities in search of the fitting cadaver. Derian and Watson push Lubbock to attempt to keep in mind extra about than man, past his tongue, and she or he does piece collectively a normal description of what he seemed like, based mostly on varied issues that occurred through the class.
In the meantime, again on the clinic, the Crofts uncover that there are a handful of pages pulled out of considered one of Lubbock’s journals. She reveals that she lately took these pages out to provide to an artist pal who wished to revisit his outdated work. It seems, when she was in school, she let this man she was seeing — Micah — be a part of her within the morgue, which led to the dangerous blood between her and Brenda. They head over to his gallery to see if he nonetheless has the pages, and uncover much more than who their “John Doe” is. Dr. Lubbock is Micah’s muse and each wall in his artwork gallery is roofed in superbly crafted work of her. Lubbock exhibits off her engagement ring to her outdated flame and simply brushes apart the truth that she’s his creative inspiration, however Derian doesn’t let this piece of data go.
Micah exhibits the three medical doctors the sketches and Dr. Watson spots a tattoo on the person’s physique that reminds him of a quilt he was gifted by an Amish neighborhood the place he and his soon-to-be-ex-wife Mary (Rochelle Aytes) obtained engaged. So away they go on regardless of the reverse of a rumspringa is. In Lancaster, the Amish people determine the sketches of Lubbock’s cadaver as a person named Jason who broke away from them years in the past. Whereas Jacob is lifeless, they level the medical doctors within the route of his sister, Rachel Smith, who lives in Harrisburg.

Associated
That Major Twist in ‘Watson’s Premiere Just Changed Everything About the Show
The brand new CBS sequence picks up six months after the demise of Sherlock Holmes.
After they lastly find Rachel, she doesn’t present any outward signs of carrying Cowden Syndrome like her brother, however she reveals that her son, Amos, has been ailing — and he has a mysterious lump on his thyroid that has medical doctors puzzled. As they transport Amos and his mom to Pittsburgh for additional evaluation, the kid begins to have issue respiratory. As soon as he’s on the hospital, it’s clear that there’s one thing incorrect with him, however it’s not the syndrome they had been satisfied he had. Dr. Watson orders Lubbock and Stephens to go dig by way of the trash on the Smiths’ home and to look your complete home for something suspicious, and this feels very very similar to the unethical practices of House.
Lubbock and Stephens uncover a bouquet of flowers sitting on the desk, which appears suspicious at first as a result of the lily is the one flower that hasn’t wilted, however that isn’t the revelatory a part of their discovery. Rachel had positioned the flowers in a milk jug from the dairy the place she bought camel milk. Watson is ready to rapidly deduce that the unpasteurized camel’s milk that the Amish apparently love was what prompted Amos’ sickness. Whereas Jason’s Cowden Syndrome led the medical doctors to determine plenty of Amish sufferers with early types of most cancers, Rachel and her son weren’t carriers for the dysfunction.
‘Watson’s Characters Are Lastly Beginning to Get Attention-grabbing
For the reason that begin of the sequence, there have been hints that Stephens has a crush on Lubbock. It’s onerous to inform if it’s reciprocated, however she does appear to preen underneath his consideration, and given the best way her fake engagement goes, she’s in dire want of a bit of TLC. The pair spend numerous time collectively all through the episode, and a few of that point entails Stephens asking politely probing questions on her wedding ceremony plans and lingering seems to be. The revelation about her not-quite-ex’s creative obsession along with her and the straightforward approach she brushes off the plain affection of somebody who really needs her sheds fairly a bit of sunshine on who she is as an individual. And, surprisingly, it’s Dr. Derian who sees by way of the bullshit.
Towards the tip of the episode, Derian asks to satisfy Lubbock at Micha’s gallery, the place she calls her out on her pretend engagement and accuses her of solely chasing after individuals who don’t really need her. Derian (who’s a personality in sore want of precise character improvement) warns Lubbock that her boyfriend is stringing her alongside and that she deserves higher than that in a transfer that nearly passes for real care for an additional human. Whether or not this warning will function a wake-up name for Lubbock and set the stage for one thing occurring between her and Stephens is but to be seen.
However Lubbock and Stephens are removed from essentially the most compelling not-couple in Watson. That honor goes to Watson and his very soon-to-be-ex-wife Mary. Earlier than the title card even seems, Watson — with the assistance of Shinwell (Ritchie Coster) — deduces that his curious assortment of inexperienced markers is definitely Mary’s approach of getting his consideration. He’s been lax on establishing a gathering between their legal professionals to start mediation, and annoying him with inexperienced markers was the one approach to get his consideration. Watson agrees to attend their subsequent mediation assembly, however he fails to indicate up as a result of he’s on the street making an attempt to unravel their “Affected person Query Mark” thriller. It’s potential that this is likely one of the essential causes for his or her divorce and never simply his friendship with the late Sherlock Holmes.
There’s some tragic irony in the best way issues play out in Episode 4, as their journey into Amish nation resurfaces numerous outdated recollections for Watson, notably the place Mary is worried. In spite of everything, they obtained engaged in Amish nation and — as a flashback reveals — the 2 met over their first cadaver. By the tip of the episode, Watson has made peace with the truth that his marriage has seemingly run its course. As soon as the case is solved, he heads over to her home to apologize for lacking mediation and promise he gained’t miss one other assembly, principally as a result of he has determined he gained’t contest the divorce. If Mary needs to be achieved with their marriage, then he gained’t stand in the best way of her determination. It’s a noble determination, however after solely 4 episodes with these two, it’s a felony offense if their chemistry doesn’t lead them again into wedded bliss.
However bliss appears to be a largely unachievable factor for this forged of characters — notably Shinwell who continues to be doing the bidding of the mysterious Moriarty (Randall Park), who Dr. Derian reveals was one of many few those who Watson noticed as a peer. Whereas we’re removed from understanding the particulars behind Moriarty’s torment of Watson, Episode 4 lastly begins to delve deeper into what Porsche (Sofie Kane) has Shinwell is doing. The pair have one other clandestine assembly the place Porsche offers Shinwell a cellphone to make use of within the lab that may sync with the laboratory robotic, Clyde, and add details about the genomes of the sufferers they’re working with. The explanation behind the directive isn’t precisely defined, however not less than it’s a begin. Shinwell can be interested by what Porsche is as much as, so he sticks a tracker on her automobile and follows her to the hospital. As an alternative of nefarious felony exercise, Shinwell watches Porsche wheel a sick little one into the hospital, which doesn’t fully match up along with her duplicitous nature. Evidently, it’s a thriller for an additional week, as a result of Watson goes no additional with this subplot this week.
After three episodes, Watson is lastly beginning to stake its declare within the community TV panorama, although it stays to be seen if it may possibly dwell as much as the varied sequence that it’s taking a web page from. However one factor is for certain, new episodes of Watson premiere Sundays on CBS.

Watson
Watson Episode 4 is mixing issues up — and it’s a welcome change of tempo.
- Launch Date
-
January 26, 2025
- Community
-
CBS
- Showrunner
-
Craig Sweeny
- Episode 4 delivers much-needed character improvement as Watson begins to search out its stride.
- Watson’s characters are nonetheless onerous to get a real really feel for, making it onerous to totally join with a few of their subplots.
- Watson is bread-crumbing the Moriarty storyline a bit of an excessive amount of for a sequence that has dropped viewers into the center of the plot.