By Matt Egan and Alicia Wallace, CNN
(CNN) — Elon Musk, wielding a chainsaw, is overseeing a speedy shrinking of the nation’s largest employer: the federal authorities.
There’s little doubt the federal authorities’s 3.02 million-person civilian workforce is huge. But some economists are assured the widespread terminations spearheaded by Musk’s Division of Authorities Effectivity (DOGE) will possible not devastate the nationwide economic system and even topple the historically strong jobs market.
“It’s not going to tip the economic system into recession by itself,” mentioned Stephanie Roth, chief economist at Wolfe Analysis.
That’s partially as a result of the federal layoffs are anticipated to have an effect on a small fraction of the a lot bigger US labor power. The federal civilian workforce, which excludes army personnel and workers of the CIA and different army companies, represents lower than 2% of the total civilian labor force of 170.7 million.
Nonetheless, the mass layoffs within the public sector threaten to upend the livelihoods of federal staff and their households, in addition to destabilize a historically secure financial engine inside many communities.
“These are actual individuals. It’s an actual hit. This isn’t one thing we must be celebrating,” mentioned Joe Brusuelas, chief economist at RSM.
Drop within the bucket
There stays appreciable uncertainty over simply what number of federal staff have been laid off and what number of extra will probably be let go within the coming days, weeks and months. That uncertainty is magnified by ongoing authorized challenges and threats by Musk for deeper cuts.
As CNN has reported, thousands of probationary workers (who’ve sometimes been employed for lower than a yr or two) have been laid off throughout varied authorities companies, together with the departments of Power, Training and Veterans Affairs in addition to on the Small Enterprise Administration and the Client Monetary Safety Bureau.
Roth expects the variety of probationary job cuts to ultimately climb to round 80,000, up from her present estimate of about 20,000. Greater than 200,000 workers have labored with the federal authorities for lower than a yr, in keeping with 2024 information compiled by the US Workplace of Personnel Administration.
Brusuelas expects the DOGE layoffs to finally get rid of between 200,000 and 300,000 jobs within the federal authorities. One other 450,000 contractors — a lot of them veterans — may very well be susceptible to dropping their jobs, too.
That’s on prime of the roughly 77,000 employees who have already accepted the Trump administration’s deferred resignation presents. The presents usually permit staff to depart their jobs however proceed to receives a commission by the top of September.
“It’s a tragedy, but it surely’s not going to influence the route of the general economic system,” Brusuelas mentioned, including that many laid-off authorities staff may discover jobs within the personal sector.
However even when the mass layoffs aren’t sufficient to set off a recession, they don’t come with out danger, mentioned Ron Hetrick, senior labor economist at Lightcast, a labor market information and analysis agency.
“It places the variable of uncertainty into the equation. And uncertainty is absolutely dangerous for the economic system and for labor markets, as a result of uncertainty means everyone pauses,” he mentioned. “That’s what the most important (financial) danger is within the quick run proper now.”
Broader financial issues
Economists are paying further shut consideration to weekly jobless claims information in addition to future jobs experiences for indicators of accelerating stress within the labor market.
Additionally, not all laid-off workers are leaving the federal workforce. Some have been reinstated and others may turn out to be authorities contractors, possible at a better pay charge.
“We may have a state of affairs the place the labor market information doesn’t deteriorate practically as a lot as individuals are fearing,” mentioned Ernie Tedeschi, director of economics on the Price range Lab at Yale College and a former prime economist within the Biden White Home.
After all, the federal layoffs are usually not happening in a vacuum.
Companies are grappling with financial uncertainty and doubtlessly greater prices attributable to the Trump administration’s tariffs, amongst different conflicting forces. On the optimistic aspect, companies have expressed optimism about potential advantages from tax cuts and deregulation.
Some economists count on President Donald Trump’s immigration crackdown to have a far larger impact on the roles market than the federal layoffs.
The federal layoffs may enhance the 4% unemployment charge by 0.05 proportion level, in keeping with Wolfe Analysis. That’s dwarfed by the 0.2 proportion level hit to the unemployment charge that Wolfe Analysis tasks from the immigration crackdown.
‘We had been hoping we’d be protected’
Economists say the DOGE-led layoffs can have a profound influence on native economies the place federal employment is concentrated.
Think about that about 23% of federal civilian staff are positioned in Maryland, Virginia and Washington, DC, in keeping with a December report from the Congressional Analysis Service.
Mass layoffs within the Beltway may power some residents to place their properties up on the market at depressed values, denting the true property market. Native companies that depend on federal staff may very well be harm, too.
“The DC economic system goes to really feel it fairly deeply. There generally is a domino impact to native companies,” mentioned Tedeschi.
Nevertheless it’s not simply the Beltway in danger.
Emma Freerks, a 24-year-old dwelling in Iowa Metropolis, Iowa, discovered on Valentine’s Day that she was being laid off from her job as a bodily science technician on the US Geological Survey.
“I used to be shocked, however not shocked,” Freerks informed CNN in a telephone interview. “We had been hoping we’d be protected as a result of our division brings in cash to the federal government.”
Earlier than her termination, Freerks had hoped to use for civil servant pupil mortgage forgiveness to deal with her $25,000 of pupil debt. She worries the federal layoffs are doing extra hurt than good.
“They spent all this cash coaching me, and that’s going to waste,” Freerks mentioned. “Now I’ll need to go on unemployment, which continues to be government-funded.”
The ripple results
In some areas, federal jobs make up 6% or 7% of whole employment, together with sure congressional districts in Alabama, Alaska, Colorado, Missouri, New Mexico, Ohio, Oklahoma, North Carolina, Texas and Washington.
In Kansas Metropolis, Missouri, the place about 30,000 federal workers work, the Inner Income Providers is the town’s largest employer, mentioned Donna Ginther, and economics professor and director of the Institute for Coverage & Social Analysis on the College of Kansas.
“And these are high-paying jobs,” she mentioned. “Some have estimated that there are about 3,000 workers susceptible to being laid off within the Kansas Metropolis space.”
Nonetheless, the native economic system would have problem absorbing these layoffs, she mentioned, noting present job listings requiring a bachelor’s diploma.
“As well as, there’s a multiplier impact,” she added. “At any time when any individual loses their jobs, they get unemployment, which solely covers a small portion of their whole wages, in order that they cease consuming within the native economic system.”
It additionally goes properly past client spending.
“The opposite half is that (the administration) is ending authorities contracts, and so they’re slicing expenditures to universities,” mentioned Marcus Casey, an affiliate professor on the College of Illinois at Chicago’s Division of Economics.
Not solely are these locations that will align carefully with federal staff’ skillsets, however cuts to these anchor establishments have vital downstream results as properly, he added.
That would spell concern for locations in Colorado, particularly communities in Boulder County the place federal labs have operated for many years and contributed to a high-tech ecosystem.
“Not solely are we involved in regards to the jobs themselves and that they’re high-wage jobs, however (additionally) the analysis perform that they play and the downstream impacts that these jobs even have,” mentioned Brian Lewandowski, govt director of the Enterprise Analysis Division on the College of Colorado’s Leeds Faculty of Enterprise.
As startup-friendly Boulder and Colorado have seen so typically: early-stage analysis finally results in additional analysis or commercialization down the highway.
Whereas there are some potential silver linings from makes an attempt to right-size the federal authorities and curb federal spending, the uncertainty extends past near-term job losses, Lewandowski mentioned.
“I feel there are a few dangers (to federal cuts), one which’s entrance of thoughts for me is the chance to innovation,” he mentioned. “I feel one other clear danger is that when that is disrupted, how straightforward or onerous is it to ever put again collectively? Will we lose one thing distinctive that’s been constructed over many a long time?”
The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2025 Cable Information Community, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Firm. All rights reserved.
