Just over 800 years in the past, within the autumn of 1224, a small band of surprisingly dressed males landed at Dover. They have been the primary ambassadors in England of a brand new non secular motion that was sweeping throughout Europe, impressed by the preaching and instance of Francis of Assisi. These first Franciscans dressed, ate and lived with ostentatious simplicity: a up to date chronicler marvelled that they walked barefoot, even within the snow, and drank nothing however the thick dregs of beer. Although they often met with derision and hostility, their order would come to have a profound affect on medieval society.
The Franciscans, with their dedication to radical poverty, are one of many case research chosen by Annette Kehnel in The Inexperienced Ages for instance of ‘medieval improvements in sustainability’. ‘There have been occasions once we people knew the constraints of our planet higher than we do now’, she says, arguing that we must always look to the previous for tactics of sharing and conserving the Earth’s assets extra sustainably. If capitalism has pushed us to the brink of ecological disaster, premodern economies could supply helpful different fashions. Although she doesn’t suggest a wholesale return to a medieval economic system, Kehnel means that historical past can present inspiration, ‘to awaken our sense of the chances on the market, and to assist us to suppose outdoors now defunct thought patterns’.
To this finish, she discusses how premodern European societies handled points such because the truthful distribution of pure assets, experiments in communal dwelling, and recycling. From fisheries in Lake Constance to forestry administration in Alsace and pasture lands within the Alps, she skilfully describes how the communities which relied on these assets developed collective strategies of dealing with them sustainably, because it was in everybody’s curiosity to make sure they remained productive in the long run.
Medieval monasteries are recognized as a mannequin for what Kehnel calls ‘sharing communities’, since their dedication to communal dwelling and the shrewd administration of their estates usually introduced them nice prosperity. She writes with explicit heat about beguinages, a particular form of semi-monastic group discovered largely in Belgium and the Netherlands within the later Center Ages. These have been city settlements shaped of single lay ladies who needed to reside in an enclosed group with out having to take non secular vows. Such ladies loved the advantages of collective organisation, whereas retaining management of their very own property; the beguinage gave them extra flexibility than a convent, although they nonetheless needed to depart in the event that they needed to marry.
Regardless of the guide’s subtitle, not all of the examples chosen are medieval. Most are drawn from Western Europe within the late Center Ages, however a number of prolong nicely into the seventeenth and 18th centuries. One chapter takes in historical Greece, the place Diogenes the Cynic, dwelling in a ceramic storage jar within the Athenian market, is hailed as a forerunner of minimalism and the tiny home motion. This historic breadth is smart, as a result of the guide doesn’t search to determine any particularly medieval attitudes to sustainability. With a number of the practices Kehnel discusses, akin to repairing damaged gadgets quite than throwing them away, you solely have to return just a few generations to seek out higher methods of doing issues; the hole just isn’t between medieval attitudes and fashionable ones, however between the previous couple of a long time and most of human historical past.
Most of the case research Kehnel places ahead are attractively described, and it’s refreshing to see such a constructive argument about what might be realized from premodern methods of dwelling. Nevertheless, the emphasis on financial fashions does depart some questions unanswered. How far can the financial benefits of those sustainability initiatives realistically be disentangled from their cultural and social context? The prosperity of medieval monasteries, as an illustration, was underpinned by the rigorously regulated nature of their communal life, which allowed them to perform however may show distinctly much less palatable at present: strict hierarchy, constraints on private relationships, uniformity in costume and subjection of the person will to the nice of the group. Greater than this, they have been held collectively by an agreed set of non secular beliefs and ethical norms, which have been continuously strengthened by instructing and sanctions for individuals who transgressed. Are you able to get rid of all these issues and count on to reap the advantages of communal dwelling in the identical method?
The Inexperienced Ages does a neat job of translating premodern practices into language which may enchantment to fashionable secular society: retro concepts akin to frugality and abstinence sound extra enticing when you name them sustainability, minimalism and eco-conscious dwelling. Within the course of, although, we could lose sight of simply how radical a problem a few of these ideologies might current to their very own time, not to mention to ours. If Diogenes or Francis of Assisi preached what we might at present name minimalism, it was as one a part of visionary philosophies that set them in opposition to all of the values of up to date society, not solely its financial priorities. Maybe solely the romance and drama of such transformative visions might be inspiring sufficient to encourage adherents to make big sacrifices. In spite of everything, individuals didn’t be a part of the Franciscans and drink beer dregs as a result of they needed to preserve beer assets, however as a result of they thought it might carry them nearer to God.
Within the absence of a equally highly effective ideology, what may stimulate our post-religious society to sacrifice consolation and comfort for extra sustainable methods of dwelling? It’s an pressing query, and to reply it we could nicely achieve inspiration from trying to the previous. Nevertheless, we would discover that those that confronted the assumptions of their very own society are nonetheless capable of problem us – and never solely in methods we would like.
-
The Inexperienced Ages: Medieval Improvements in Sustainability
Annette Kehnel, translated by Gesche Ipsen
Profile, 320pp, £22
Purchase from bookshop.org (affiliate hyperlink)
Eleanor Parker is a columnist at Historical past Right now.
